Atwater's in The Herrington
Beautiful place with wonderful food and service! Will definately go back!
Lovely atmosphere! Beautiful location! Fine dining at it's best! Strongly recommended!
Excellent all around! Wait staff was great and the food was awesome!
Both steaks, while a high quality of meat and seasoned well, were extremely over cooked.
Atwater’s has a wonderful location on the Fox River. Indoor and outdoor seating but be prepared to dine quietly inside. Great dining experience. The chef sent out ceviche on a chip to cleanse the palette and the best fresh baked cream puffs ever for dessert. Service was awesome as expected. Prices are high but not crazy high all considered.
Good food, service and ambience!
Ambiance was very comfortable along with the quiet service of the staff. Lunch was 2 of their fish offerings. Delicious. Will come back again.
Beautiful view, quiet and cozy
This is fine dining! And a perfect place to have celebrated our wedding anniversary.
Very nice room! Beautiful view. Food was very good....filet and lamb chops. We enjoyed the entire experience. Recently moved to Geneva and have been wanting to try Atwater's. It did not disappoint!
Our server, Renee, was excellent! Food was expensive but good! Chef sent out a few extras throughout the meal which was very nice! Chef is obviously very good at his profession!
Wonderful meal on a beautiful day from their patio overlooking the Fox river.
The service left a lot to be desired but the ambiance was great.
It was a lovely night in Geneva. We opted on sitting outside and it was a good choice. Our server did a great job and our food was excellent.
We celebrated our 12th anniversary at the Herrington - where we also married!
The service was wonderful and the food, amazing! Especially the Lamb! We will definitely return again!!
Everything about our dining experience was wonderful, especially the setting and the service. All dishes were delicious and I highly recommend this beautiful restaurant tucked into the Herrington Inn in Geneva, Illinois. We chose to sit in the courtyard adjacent to the dining room. Landscaped beautifully, we enjoyed the Fox River and enjoyed this tranquil setting, even though the day was hot. I only wish they could drop the prices a bit, but our lunch at the Atwater was worth the splurge. I ordered the crab cake appetizer and the Atwater salad. The portions were ample and perfect for lunch. The wait staff were friendly, attentive, yet did not hover or intrude. All around good experience!
As consistently good as always. The pork chop was so tender!
A perfect dining experience with excellent food and attentive service.
Atwater’s has been a favorite elegant dining spot for special occasions. The food is always amazing, the service impeccable, and the atmosphere quiet and romantic. And it has been consistently excellent for the over 15 years that we have been coming here!
Having a late afternoon lunch we wanted a quiet,lovely experience, it was all of that except for some of the food.
My husband had a petite filet and it was wonderful, I, on the other hand had come especially for the Dover sole, I am not convinced it was sole, fried, dry, draped over the worse cous cous I have ever tried to eat
This is the place of you like slow service and cold food with high prices.
Always a good spot for a special occasion. This was our 25th year celebrating our anniversary.
They gave us the best table in the restaurant for our anniversary and left hand signed cards for us from the staff wishing congratulations!!!
Simply an amazing experience!
Breakfast took over 30 minutes once we placed are order.
I choose this place for my first date with a special young lady and we had a wonderful time.
The staff is excellent and the hotel and restaurant pristine
A truly exceptional experience. The venue and atmosphere was romantic and dignified. Waiter was exceptionally knowledgeable. Food was beyond expectations. We had the Filet and the Rack of Lamb which were some of the best we have ever had. Highly recommended for very special occasions.
Nice restaurant for a fancy brunch. Beautiful views of the Fox River. Attentive and friendly staff. Delicious food and drinks.
Wonderful food! I had the blackberry sauced salmon; husband had the blueberry compote with duck. We enjoyed everything we ordered and the service was both friendly and professional. It is a pricey restaurant but worth the cost for a special event. Beautiful view of the Fox River as well.
My husband had the best lamb off his life and the mushroom risotto was fabulous. Service was terrific, everyone was very nice
The service at Atwater was wonderful. Unfortunately the food didn’t rise to the same level. Out of our party of four, only one really enjoyed her dish. Luckily she was the birthday girl we were there to celebrate! She had the filet and it was very good. The other 3 of us found our dishes to be mediocre with flavor combinations that just didn’t match well with our palettes. When you pay for a higher end restaurant, you expect to really enjoy the food. I’d say the best thing we had were the cocktails. The salmon and red snapper were both disappointing and the mushroom risotto, was ok, but not anything special.
Fantastic dinner. Michael was a great server. We will be back.
Great meal, meat & seafood were done perfectly.
Service was friendly and professional. Nice wine list.
Very nice small dining room that becomes loud when full.
Outstanding food, service and ambiance as always. Love this place and highly recommend.
We had a late reservation on a Saturday night and were not rushed and treated as if we were the only guests in the room. The food and service were perfection. Really need the molten chocolate cake recipe....just saying!
The Earl Gray Filet Mignon was one of the best steaks I ever had. We loved the half bottles of wine and our server, Michael, was wonderful.
We had a lovely Mother’s Day dinner! Service was very attentive in a lovely setting overlooking the Fox River!
We had a delicious dinner with excellent service. However, a large party in the room increased the noise level greatly.