The Dining Room at Castle Hill Inn
Wonderful food and service
Thank you Mimi! We are very happy you enjoyed.
Incredible service, great location (wish is was daylight) food was somewhat not exceptional compared to everything else at Castle Hill Inn
Thank you for joining us Mark and yes, although we love the charm of the Inn at night, there is something about the sun shining here. We wish our food had made a better impression on you as our culinary team works hard to deliver an exceptional menu to our guests. We want your visit to Castle Hill to exceed your expectations form start to finish.
We ate at the Castle Hill Inn 4 years ago. We've been meaning to return ever since. It is a fabulous restaurant! The service is perfect, and every single bite was delicious!
Thank you for coming back and so happy you enjoyed it all. We hope we see you again soon.
Always an experience. Food, wine, staff are all 5 star.
Thank you Annlen. We are very happy you enjoyed and honored to be considered a 5-star spot.
Vegetarian entree was pumpkin risotto. No visible pumpkin, so mostly rice. Service was impeccable though
Thank you Diane. We will share with our culinary team. We always want our vegetarian offerings to be thoroughly enjoyed.
An excellent choice for a special occasion. My wife and I had dinner at The Dining Room during Christmas Eve and we had an amazing dining experience. Tasty foods and beautiful presentation of dishes. Excellent ingredient quality, very flavorful too. The wine list is extensive, the cocktails are delicious (the painkiller is to die for), the service is impeccable. Warm, cozy and upscale atmosphere in the winter - more casual and upbeat in the summer with a younger crowd. The highlight of our meal the 24th was the squash agnolotti and the seared scallops. We received gingerbread cookies at our departure which were very tasty and very cute! I highly recommend this restaurant and look forward to our next visit - hopefully staying at the Inn this time!
Thank you for joining us for Christmas Eve and we are very happy you and your wife enjoyed. We appreciate your recommendation and look forward to seeing you again. We hope you do stay at the Inn next time too. It's always a relaxing time.
A wonderful experience
So glad you enjoyed!
Best dining on the island. Dining here is truly amazing experience. Great experiences like Castle Hill are not cheap! However, certainly well worth it.
Thank you Jeremy! It's always an honor to be considered the best on the island. We are very happy you enjoyed.
Always grateful for our guests too! Glad you enjoyed.
Food was good as is the old world Newport ambiance. Bring a lot of money cuz it's pricey.
Thank you for the feedback. We are glad you enjoyed your meal.
We had a wonderful meal for my wife's birthday. We traveled down from the Boston area just to eat there.
Thank you Stan! We are honored you chose to celebrate with us and glad you enjoyed.
One of the best meals I've had in years. The wine pairings and service were fantastic. I'd love to return!
Thank you Rebecca! We are honored to be considered one of your best meals. We are so glad you enjoyed and hope that you do have the chance to join us again.
It was my first choice for a restaurant when my aunt and uncle told us they were visiting from Florida. We were running late for our reservation, bit they didn’t mind and welcomed us when we finally got there. The server (and I apologize sincerely that I forgot her name) but she was wonderful and very friendly. The meal was delicious and the atmosphere was perfect. I requested the smaller dining
room for warmth and easy to socialize which they accommodated. My family were very impressed and mu husband and I look forward to our next date night at Castle Hill!!!
Thank you MOC4879. We are thrilled that you chose Castle Hill as the ideal spot for your visiting relatives and more importantly, we are glad you all enjoyed. Our servers work hard to ensure our guests have a memorable night. Thank you for recognizing this and we are looking forward to seeing you back here again soon.
Dining at Castle Hill is a culinary experience. Its not just a 5 star restaurant, the food quality goes well above to this so that guests truly get to experience where master chefs can go with tastes' and flavors in a culinary adventure. If you have not been to Castle Hill in a while you may want to visit this restaurant as they have well above the food quality that you might have experience just a few years ago. Bon Appetit !
Thank you Paul and we are very happy you enjoyed. You have shared some truly kind words with us and we are grateful. We hope you continue to join us for more experiences where we look forward to seeing you again.
What an anniversary dinner. We had a nice table next to the window and could see the Newport bridge lit up.
We opted for the three course fixed price dinner option with wine pairing.
Our service throughout was top notch by the entire service team. Our lead server walked us through each meal option with wine and did outstanding.
For the first course my wife had the oysters and I had the squash soup. Best we ever had.
Next my wife had the duck and I had the beef filet. My wife enjoyed her duck but thought it was slightly over cooked and smelt a little gamey. My filet was cooked to perfection with nice flavors. Overall we both enjoyed them.
For desert I had the soufflé and my wife chocolate ganache. Both were top notch.
The wines that were paired were all excellent. However some of the pours seemed a little light.
This is a great restaurant for a special occasion. It was worth the money for a special night but the most expensive meal we ever had.
We will go back.
Thank you for choosing us for your anniversary celebration and we are very happy you both enjoyed. We appreciate your kind words and we are thrilled to hear you will be joining us again.
Overall great food and restaurant. Service was good and there were plenty of staff on hand. My sense was the staff was new or maybe the winter staff. The doorman didn't seem to speak at all which seemed a little off. Food was excellent with several rounds of free treats from the kitchen. Was a birthday celebration and I'd asked for a cake or something when I booked the reservation... after dinner they brought a mini cake with a candle- it was delicious. We were also given a free jar of gooseberry jam, also excellent.
Thank you for joining us Greg and glad you enjoyed. We appreciate your feedback too. We strive for a five-star experience with every guest. We will discuss your comments with the team as we always want to be better where we can. We hope you choose to join us again.
Great evening part of Newport Restaurant Week
Thank you for joining us.
Delightful meal served by professional, friendly wait staff.
Thank you David! We are very happy you enjoyed and grateful you chose to dine with us.
We booked this restaurant for Newport Restaurant Week. First time there and we enjoyed it immensely. Everything was classy including our server was dressed in a suit. He was knowledgeable about the history of the mansion and a superb server. The food was phenomenal. We live 1.5 hours away and will gladly do the long trek again soon since it was one of the most enjoyable dining experience.
Thank you Leo and Jane. We always love Restaurant Week as it brings new guests to Castle Hill. We are so happy you enjoyed too. Thank you for making the trip and we sincerely hope you come back and join us again.
The service, attention and atmosphere are exceptional. The details and extras are amazing. The food was excellent ,the variety was excellent.
Thank you RIdiner! We are truly grateful you enjoyed and hope we see you again soon.
CH knows what they’re doing. The atmosphere, charm and beauty of the property are impeccable. The service and food are unmatched.
It was our anniversary and they surprised us with complimentary champagne too; nice touch!
We will be back. Thanks so much for a wonderful evening!!
Thank you Aaron and we are thrilled you had a wonderful evening. We are grateful for your kind words and we are looking forward to having the pleasure of serving you again.
The service was outstanding, especially Nick. Patient and attentive with all our questions, and all his recommendations were spot on. Food was 5 star. Butternut squash soup was incredible, and the duck was prepared perfectly. Overall highly recommended. Very pleased with our choice to celebrate our anniversary. Will be sure to include Castle Hill Inn on our next trip to Newport. Thanks again to all the staff for a wonderful experience.
Thank you for celebrating your Anniversary with us! We are so happy to hear you had a great time and are looking forward to joining us again. Thank you for your recommendation.
Fabulous dinner and view... highly recommend it!!!
Thank you MeganM.
Based on our recent experience, the restaurant fell short of our usual fine experience there.
Service was inattentive, very slow, a long wait from appetizer to entree, 7:15 arrival, entree served at 8:30 Had to ask for water to be refilled. Extremely salty swordfish entree, experienced by three diners in our party... Disappointing for the price.
Thank you for joining us last week, and for taking the time to provide feedback as well. I'm terribly sorry to hear that we fell short of expectations on this experience. It sounds like we were not on the mark in terms of food quality and timing, and even worse that we were not attentive enough to rectify while you were here with us. I hope you might find the time to speak directly so we can see how to make this right. I look forward to hearing from you, and hope to see you again soon.
Beautifully scenic. The food is delicious and the staff is very attentive and accommodating.
Thank you Raw1087.