10 oz. Filet Broiled to your liking. All of our Steaks are Char-Broiled to your liking with Prime's Signature Seasoning & Served with Fresh Oven Roasted Garlic, Red Wine Demi-glaze and Fresh Rosemary
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
Key Lime Pie
Licor 43, Sobieski Vanilla, fresh lime juice & cream with a graham cracker crust
Good was great but the server was rude at some points during dinner, didn’t want to answer our questions or gave attitude in his answer, other then that very good dinner
Visited 2 nights in a row for same meal - filet w bone in, conch chowder, shrimp cocktail, and fries! So delicious. Great ambiance
Made a special anniversary even better. Special menu even. Thanks for a great memorable dinner
Service was great! I had the filet cooked medium rare. It was cooked properly, but lacking flavor. My fiancé ordered the ribeye, also medium rare. It was served rare, but he insisted it was still delicious. The gouda mac and cheese was the star of the show! Overall pleasant experience.
We made reservations through opentable. The only thing available at that time was a high top at the bar-which was fine with us. However, I don’t think the bartender could handle the bar plus the high tops. My wine sat empty but he was too busy to notice. My husband got a filet which was very tender and great flavor. I ordered the fish of the day which was pretty good but the asparagus that came with the meal was not flavored at all-like they came straight from the garden. We also got a side of Mac & cheese which tasted so smoky we couldn’t eat it. However, we were compensated for that. Overall our experience was “ok”. We love to support key west restaurants and have several amazing experiences. I asked my husband if he would want to return to Prime during our next visit and we both weren’t too confident that we would. The reasoning behind that is we’ve had much better service other places. However, we aren’t ones to write an establishment off based on one visit so we will probably come back again at some point. I just wanted to give my honest opinion. Thanks for having us!
Great as always!
We went for Thanksgiving and they had a wonderful meal gave a lot of food for the price.
The Food and Service was amazing. One of , if not , the best restaurant in Key West . We will definitely return !
We sat outside with Kim and she was amazing! We loved our meals. She was super attentive to our kids. We go back every year.
Delicious food and excellent service. Highly recommend
This is our new go to restaurant. Our server Nate was the ultimate professional. Everything from the minute we walked in was truely amazing. The hostess, the bartender, Nate our server, the chefs you all should be commended.
Food was good.
Our waiter Moses was knowledgeable informative and very helpful and courteous. He helped us out with Key West nightlife, picking out the correct bourbon and even made some great menu suggestions. On top of that best meal we had in Key West and in a long time elsewhere. Will be dining again next time in Key West.
Anniversary 15 years
Was nice and fun and convenient since we were staying on our boat right out front.
Very nice atmosphere
We had the crabcske for appetizers omg freaking delicious the we shared the 24oz bone in ribeye the meat melted in your mouth
Server was awesome. We were able to get private seating for 2 that was really romantic! Steaks and lobster were a bit over-cooked, but we didn’t want any hassle so we didn’t report it. Would highly recommend and go back.
Mary is absolutely amazing. Attentive, kind and has a great sense of humor. She's one of the finest servers I have encountered.
The food? WOW. The best steak in all of the Keys. The drinks are fun and potent. The soup? Delicious. Absolutely top notch.
We are vacationing and wanted something that wasn’t seafood. Everything is a la carte, but everything was delicious. It is expensive, but the food was on par. Service was impeccable. Only negative was it’s odd location and very dark atmosphere inside. Highly recommend if you want a good steak!
The best meal we had in Key West! The steaks were superb! The lobster delicate and sweet! Fantastic! Mary did her very best to get our group of 9 close together at the last minute!
Andre our server and Mary the manager on duty were outstanding!! Great service, very friendly. Fantastic steaks.
Dinner was excellent -the service was very good as were the steaks. One issue - they had a special entre - fettuccini with shrimp. One of our guests wanted a half order- as a side with their steak. Our server when asked simply said no. Not let me check - etc. other then that - very happy with the restaurant.
Outstanding service and the food was delicious. Steak was prepared perfectly and one of the best we’ve ever had. Lobster was also cooked just right and it was delicious. Service was awesome. Everything about our dining experience was great. Make sure to dine here when you’re in Key West.
We had an amazing dinner! Our steaks were done perfectly! Great wine list and our server Alessio was fantastic and the best we've had yet in Key West. Couldn't say more good things.
We had a great dining experience with amazing food and cocktails.
The food was delicious. My steak was prepared to perfection and the chicken was tender. The seasoning was great on booth entree’s. I would visit again the next time I’m here.
A little difficult to find. It’s upstairs if you’re following a gps guide. We walked around the building searching & finally went upstairs.
The food was excellent. Great she crab soup & Caesar salad. Fresh catch of the day was tasty. The ribeye was good according to my husband.
The place was dark. Very dark. Waiter was nice & helpful.
Good meal. Expensive but we had been warned it would be
The escargot appetizer was amazing. The bone in filet is a must. Great food, great ambiance.
Everything was fabulous, food and service (Alex)!
As always perfect night
Kim was an excellent server and food was prepared perfectly. Consistently the best steak dinner in KW.
Ales our waiter was fantastic. Always knew when we needed him without being intrusive. Excellent!!
Food on point as always.
Outstanding as always. Meat was perfectly cooked and service was excellent.
First time, and did not disappoint! Went for a birthday dinner, based on a recommendation. I had the filet, nice crunchy crust with a super tender inside. Love the whole clove of garlic they give you!
It was awesome.
The food was amazing! The staff were very friendly and accommodating. The inside was very clean and the ambiance was nice. Great dinner!
Great service and food! Definitely would visit again.
Chefs kiss. Delish. Food was fabulous. We had a seat outside and it was a wonderful evening for dining in the fresh air. Highly recommend.
Prime Steakhouse wird von 1939 OpenTable‑Gästen mit 4.7 Sternen bewertet.
Ja, Sie können üblicherweise in diesem Restaurant reservieren, indem Sie auf OpenTable Datum, Uhrzeit und Personenzahl wählen. Aufgrund lokaler Einschränkungen nimmt dieses Restaurant derzeit möglicherweise keine Reservierungen entgegen.