Order the pear ricotta faggotini!
Such a cute and quaint restaurant with great food and service. Would come by often if I lived a little closer. You can tell the owners put a lot of pride in their place.
Amazing food and service. The pasta is delicious. I will be returning.
My new fave everyday Italian restaurant. Prices are reasonable, food is great and ambiance just right. I’ll definitely be back.
Amazing food, great ambiance, service was excellent!
Anniversary dinner, really nice, try the polenta cake with mushrooms
It was 2nd time there. And from reservation to check - it was good experience.
I am a super senior who grew up in a tenement in the Bronx with Italian neighbors all around and enjoyed what is now known by my yuppie friends as "red sauce Italian" food, which was homemade, home cooked and delicious. Barbalu was again a great place with really good food and service.
For me 5 stars are perfection - I think nothing is perfect -- but "youse guys and your place are up there."
Good food, good wines, great service. A non-pretentious neighborhood restaurant.
Wonderful. Spaghetti with Sausage and cream was incredible. Can't wait to come back in a few weeks.
Our waiter Hector was knowledgeable on everything!! We had dietary concerns and he reassured us and everything was delicious!!! The food was terrific the service was wonderful overall had a lovely evening!!! Would definitely recommend this restaurant....
I love this place. I always look for a reason to come here. Food is amazing, atmosphere is excellent and service is great! If you haven't been it's a must visit.
Barbalu is one of my favorite Italian restaurants in the city. Perfect from anything like dinner with the girls to a date night. You need to try the pear ricotta fagotini!
Great dood and ambience, will definitely dine again
We love this place. The food is well proportioned and well prepared. The wait staff is attentive, the ambiance pleasant. A good place for business lunches or to meet friends. It never disappoints.
Great vibe. Great food.
The restaurant itself was very cute and well lit. The food was absolutely incredible. We got the burrata and prosciutto appetizer and it was perfect. I got the spaghetti with sausage and cream all norcina and it was probably one of the best pasta dishes I've ever had. Definitely a solid spot, and not too hard on the wallet either.
Great for date night and hanging out with friends in general.
We had a terrific lunch here after walking around the Seaport on a rainy afternoon. The ambience is rustic urban and very inviting. All four of us really enjoyed our entrees. The fish was wild caught and prepared beautifully. We also loved the cheese platter with an excellent choice of cheeses.
Food was delicious. Service was not great.
The food was great but despite our reservation, they gave us a crappy table.
Grilled Octopus one (1) piece in dish for appetizer YES ONE piece $19.00!!!!!! Food was good. Service left something to be desired. Maybe an off night.
Beautiful restaurant with great food just blocks from Pier 17. Both pasta dishes we had were outstanding
Food was absolutely amazing!
Great food all around. Pasta wonderful.
Always great consistent authentic food. Cool waiters.
A little gem of a restaurant. Great food. Warm, efficient service. And the server was well-informed about gluten free options on the menu and how those items were prepared. So helpful and appreciated. We really had a lovely experience and will definitely go back. Highly recommend.
A let down and embarrassment. Waitstaff apparently had a very poor connection means of English. Extra dry dirty martini I was anything but. I complained and she said thank yo and walked away? Had to ask for things multiple times.
Bufalo mozzarella over eggplant was flavorless.
Saffron Gnocchi with brown Butter and sage. There was not perceptible saffron, the supposed Brown Butter was no thing more than lots f barely melted butter.
Booked restaurant to meet two clients, I was quite embarrassed. Returned with check saying “no card”, apparently she dropped card on floor :-(((
Comfortable environment, delicious dishes, and good service
Great small restaurant in Seaport. Feels like a locals hangout rather than a tourist spot, which is great. Excellent food and service.
Heard great things about this Italian restaurant and decided to finally take my dad their for his birthday and we weren’t disappointed. Reasonably priced and very attentive wait staff. Food was outstanding.
The most delicious pasta I’ve had since Italy.
We came in on a Friday evening and had a very smooth check-in, courteous and welcoming service, with the waitstaff seamlessly refilling water and taking away plates whenever necessary. All my friends and I enjoyed the cheese plate and pastas, and the wines were fantastic! I highly recommend this restaurant experience.
We were not rushed and it was very much appreciated
Ottima cucina, personale gentile e servizio ottimo!! Se volete mangiare italiano a New York qui lo trovate. Il ristorante è bellissimo ed è situato in una delle zone più belle e caratteristiche della città, il quartiere di Fulton vicino al porto. Rapporto qualità prezzo molto buono per New York!!! Consiglio vivamente!!!
Strange place: prawn and crab avocado salad was described by our waiter as a prawn in a shell with the head on. The prawn was minced in with the crab meat. Ok, tasted good, just strange description. Then dessert is called " warm souffle" it wasn't a souffle! It was warm chocolate lava cake. I wouldn't order it if i knew it wasn;t really a souffle. Otherwise the dinner was fine.
We had reservations, the waiter was extremely rude, he made us wait 30 minutes and sat a group at their table first even though they came in 20 minutes after us. I made a complaint, so they sat us near the dirty dish busser, although there were multiple tables open, it was practically an empty restaurant. The sauce on my pasta was bland, food was cold. I feel like we were given bad service intentionally because I complained about service. Don't eat here. There's many great places on the same street.
Good service, reasonable prices and menu. Convenient option at the Seaport
Enjoyed our meal. Good variety on menu. The atmosphere is very nice. Arrived while still day light, and could see outside through sun room roof. As it started to get darker, the warm interior really shined.
While the food was very good, the service was not. This could be a great spot if they focused on improving attention to customers.
Amazing staff. Delicious food. Great ambiance