Kostenlose Specials

Sunday Blues & Brunch

Prix Fixe menu & à la carte menu. 30% off bottled wines. $1 oysters.

Friday Eats & Beats

Live Music. Prix Fixe menu & à la carte menu. 30% off bottled wines.

Thursday Jazz Night

Live Jazz. Prix Fixe menu & à la carte menu. 30% off bottled wines.

Was 25 Gäste sagen
Bewertungen insgesamt
Bewertungen können nur von Gästen gemacht werden, die in diesem Restaurant gegessen haben.
3.5Basierend auf kürzlich erfolgten Ratings
3.8
Essen
3.6
Service
3.4
Ambiente
3.3
Preis-Leistung
Lärm · Gemäßigt
64 % der Gäste würden das Restaurant einem Freund empfehlen
Sortieren nach
Filter
JL
vipJamesL
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 29. Februar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

We went with another family for dinner and they had large tables to accommodate us. The manager and staff were very friendly and attentive and the restaurant had a good vibe.. We had a pizza, tuna tartare and fried Ipswich clams followed by brisket burgers and lobster rolls. Everything was delicious.

Melden
P
Pdsnyc
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 16. Februar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

There is a local band that plays a few times a week. The band played jazz and rock n roll. It was a nice vibe and very fun for a Sunday lunch.

If you’ve been to the NYC location you get that NE feel and the food is always great the same is true at Sag Harbor.

Melden
DN
vipDisappointedNYC
Raum New York
4 Bewertungen
Besucht am 15. Februar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente4

The food is always first rate. The service is among the best I have experienced. It is always a pleasure to visit Ed’s.
The freshest oysters from Montauk and the best lobster around.

Melden
DP
DaltonP
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 16. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Jazz night at Ed's Lobster Bar is always a treat! The staff are super friendly, the food is great and the musicianship is world class. My wife and I have been there four Thursdays in a row and haven't been disappointed once.

Melden
RB
vipRBRNYC
Raum New York
4 Bewertungen
Besucht am 3. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen4Service5Ambiente4

Went on a quiet Friday evening in January. Lovely host and manager, excellent service, and best of all, great food (lobster roll and burger). We even enjoyed the wines by the glass. It was very quiet and we were pleased with the value. We will definitely return!

Melden
s
vipstinky3116
Raum New York
5 Bewertungen
Besucht am 26. Dezember 2019
Gesamt2Essen2Service2Ambiente2

The ambience at Ed's is really off -- too bright for dinner. And there was no bar tender so we sent the drinks, made by the owner, back twice.

Melden
v
veronicam
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 19. Dezember 2019
Gesamt2Essen1Service3Ambiente3

went for the Jam Session; will go for that again, but eat elsewhere. The food was truly awful. How can you have lousy fish in a fishing community? No one is minding that store. But the staff were really nice.

Melden
JH
vipJoelH
Raum New York
38 Bewertungen
Besucht am 2. November 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente4

Excellent!

Melden
XX
vipXXXXX
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 28. September 2019
Gesamt1Essen1Service2Ambiente3

David, the manager, tried hard, but ultimately, the place failed to provide acceptable food or service. The place was far understaffed, which, given it being the off-season, was not intolerable. However, to have management tell us that they were too busy to make a drink, is simply bad business. Moreover, we were promised a steep discount on a bottle of wine, which, of course, did not appear on the bill (too upset to ask at the end). The server, who was brand new, tried hard, but was unable to overcome lack of basic training (gluten free specified dish came out with gluten abound), and the food simply wasn't very good. Very unfortunate as their NYC location has always delivered. I truly miss Bay Burger!

Melden
OT
vipOpenTable-Gast
Philadelphia
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 23. September 2019
Gesamt1Essen1Service1Ambiente1

Place was closed. Why did they accept the reservation if they were going to be closed.

Melden
AA
ArthurA
Raum New York
4 Bewertungen
Besucht am 7. September 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente4

We highly recommend the lobster roll.. large chunks of lobster and no filler!!! Also you must try the mussels in the lobster broth... exceptional! Their service also could not be better.. very attentive wait staff. Not much ambience... but who needs that if you go with someone you care about! We sat outside and enjoyed the informal patio.. and each other’s company.

Melden
OT
OpenTable-Gast
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 1. September 2019
Gesamt3Essen3Service2Ambiente2

We went to Ed’s after having difficulty finding a table elsewhere to finish off Labor Day weekend. Ordering was difficult and they got a few wrong items which were corrected except for one dish they kept getting wrong. My vegetables were cooked from frozen (corn and beans). Quite expensive which I understand for Sag Harbor but cost didn’t match experience and it’s not in downtown either - it’s about a mile out of cebtral Sag. Margarita was not drinkable. Tuna steak was huge but so bland I didn’t even finish it.

Won’t go back here for sure. Maybe the one in NYC offers a better experience?

Lobster roll was good as was lobster Mac and cheese. Otherwise stay away from other non-core items from menu.

Melden
p
vippattiw
Raum New York
5 Bewertungen
Besucht am 31. August 2019
Gesamt4Essen5Service4Ambiente4

Delicious Linguine with Clams & Fish ‘n Chips

Melden
F
Freddie5785
Raum New York
6 Bewertungen
Besucht am 29. August 2019
Gesamt2Essen3Service2Ambiente2

Had waited all summer to finally get to check this place out. Pretty disappointed. It's not a place for dinner it's more of a snack shack. We walked in and at first were impressed with the decor and modern look. We then waited for nearly 5 mins where no one greeted us or told us where we could sit. I had to grab someone's attention to ask if we could sit. And it wasn't busy at all. We sat at one table and had to move because it had used utensils on the table. The table we sat at next had food all over the floor and more used utensils. If you are going to charge $36 for a small lobster roll you should at least clean your restaurant. Food was overpriced and average. There's much better places that provide better service and a more reasonable and better tasting lobster roll. Nothing to see here unfortunately as I was really excited.

Melden
l
viplatts
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 29. August 2019
Gesamt3Essen3Service2Ambiente3

Food is mediocre - there is ZERO managerial staff
Second time I’ve gone and been disappointed. There will not be a third time

Melden
BD
vipBethD
Raum New York
2 Bewertungen
Besucht am 24. August 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Lobster roll was outstanding!

Melden
JM
vipJohnnyMaroneynewyork10011
Raum New York
48 Bewertungen
Besucht am 23. August 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente3

Great menu and super staff - love it. It is the classic roadside twist on modern dining.

Melden
C
vipCarrie
Raum New York
9 Bewertungen
Besucht am 23. August 2019
Gesamt4Essen5Service4Ambiente4

The food was outstanding . We had lobster roll, fish tacos and New England Clam Chowder. Highly recommend!

Melden
MR
vipMarciaR
Raum New York
41 Bewertungen
Besucht am 21. August 2019
Gesamt1Essen1Service2Ambiente1

Nothing close to quality in NYC

Melden
OT
OpenTable-Gast
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 16. August 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service4Ambiente4

Highly recommend trying this new spot. Friendly service, superior food.

Melden
w
wendym
Raum New York
6 Bewertungen
Besucht am 15. August 2019
Gesamt4Essen4Service4Ambiente5

The place is nice but pricey. They were out of the wine and appetizer we picked. Mussels were good. Fish and chips were so so. Give it a try. Maybe they were having an off night

Melden
j
vipjjhenne
San Francisco
13 Bewertungen
Besucht am 10. August 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

No need to go out to Montauk/Amagansett for a lobster roll anymore. Lobster roll was so good we went 2 days in a row. Oh...and the fries...you won’t be able to stop eating them. Best restaurant in the Hamptons!

Melden
PN
PatrickN
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 7. August 2019
Gesamt2Essen3Service3Ambiente5

Lobster roll was good, the NE clam chowder was terrible... It tasted off and was watery. I don't get the loud house music, thumping in my head, in a lobster place. 🤔 maybe I'm not the demographic target. But. Tried the restaurant and there is not much spin to a lobster roll so it doesn't stand out from any other "lobster" place on the east end or any end.

Melden
g
vipglutton
Raum New York
26 Bewertungen
Besucht am 5. August 2019
Gesamt4Essen5Service5Ambiente4

Bright, cool and casual restaurant with delicious food and drinks, great service....quiet on an early Monday evening!

Melden
J
vipJtummi
Raum New York
6 Bewertungen
Besucht am 3. August 2019
Gesamt1Essen1Service1Ambiente1

I would give zero stars if possible. Everything about this place is wrong. We went for dinner on a Saturday evening. This place should not be open for dinner. It’s a casual lunch place at best but it’s overpriced and doesn’t even try. The service was non existent. We sat outside and was attacked by mosquitoes because they didn’t think to spray their property? We had to wait over 40 mins for our bland sub-par food. We had the lobster roll which you would assume would be a specialty. It was the worst lobster roll I’ve had in the entire East End! We ordered oysters (how do you ruin that?!?). They were too small and didn’t even provide a spoon for vinegar. We had to wait 30 mins to get them too. Finally, I have to also mention the terrible drinks we ordered. They tasted like they were mixed by a 12 yr old kid. Just terrible and so embarrassing. This place will not last the season. They don’t understand where they are or what they’re doing.

Melden

FAQ

Ed's Lobster Bar - Sag Harbor bietet Lieferungen in Partnerschaft mit Uber Eats an. Ed's Lobster Bar - Sag Harbor bietet auch Takeaways an, die Sie telefonisch beim Restaurant bestellen können: (631) 725-1131.

Ed's Lobster Bar - Sag Harbor wird von 25 OpenTable‑Gästen mit 3.5 Sternen bewertet.

Reservieren Sie in diesem Restaurant, indem Sie Datum, Uhrzeit und Personenzahl wählen.