H2O Seafood & Sushi - East Islip
Brought my girlfriend here for her birthday. We had a great experience. Food was phenomenal!
Food and drink is excellent, a bit expensive, but can be Family Style.. A great place for a date night, birthday dinner, anniversary. ❤️
Friendly and efficient service. Delicious food and a nice choice of specials
We have been here several times - with and without friends - always a great dining experience. Food is prepared as requested and the service is always excellent. Nice happy hour prices at the bar and weekly specials. Menu appeals to both sea and land lovers.
Family Saturday Dinner
Always nice and quiet for Sunday Brunch. Drinks alittle pricey but over all food excellent.
Very overpriced below average seafood. My wife had fish tacos. $21.00 for 3 tacos with a few pieces of cod in it (which where supposed to be blackened but were not). I had sushi. To be honest, I have had better sushi at a supermarket. I felt like I was eating in a diner but paying high end restaurant prices. What a disappointment. Will never go back.
Please allow me to introduce myself, I am Michael Bohlsen, one of the owners of H2O. I am dismayed that your last experience was disappointing. I would like the opportunity to invite you back to H2O to see how wonderful H2O can really be. If you can send me your full name and physical mailing address, you can expect a personal invitation to return. Thank you for taking the time to let us know how you felt about your dining experience. Michael Bohlsen
Very good food. Attentive staff. Modern facility which can be noisy due to the design, especially up near the bar.
We truly enjoyed the Restaurant Week dinner selections. Our server was wonderful -- so attentive and helpful! The popovers were a lovely treat with the honey butter and our fish selections for the main course were melt in your mouth delicious. The maple vinaigrette was a delightful compliment to the salad.
The Tuna was very good, but the stuffed flounder was dry, and really a stuffed flounder rollatini, not the traditional flounder with a pile of crab meat stuffing. The watermelon margarita was excellent
Please allow me to introduce myself, I am Michael Bohlsen, one of the owners of H2O: Seafood and Sushi. I am dismayed that your last experience was disappointing. I would like the opportunity to invite you back to H2O to see how wonderful H2O can really be. If you can send me your full name and physical mailing address, you can expect a personal invitation to return. Thank you for taking the time to let us know how you felt about your dining experience. Michael Bohlsen
Great food & service, good time with friends 👍🏻🦞
The food, the service, the atmosphere, all outstanding, I've been here many times and they never fail to deliver an exceptional experience!
Good food, great drinks and great service!
Treated ourselves to sushi :) Saturday Family dinner
Dined many times at this H2O as well as the one in Smithtown. Food is consistently beyond excellent. The new skillet dessert is amazing.
Amazing people all the staff
Bartender Jolene Grace Lauren everyone fabulous
The food, service and restaurant were good. Worth the visit but we felt a little over priced.
We have eaten here many times. Always enjoy the time spent at this restaurant.
Everything runs like clockwork at H2O - good specials, reliable value, quick service. My only complaint, and I hesitate to say this, is that we were repeatedly interrupted by the manager and server asking if everything was ok!
Great food and wonderful service as usual. Always come here for special occasions.
Everything was terrific. Beautiful atmosphere. Food was delicious. Our waiter Patrick was knowledgeable, helpful, and attentive. He made our night special by being treated as quests
If the chef keeps making such eye and palate pleasing dinners we will keep coming back.
Great server and great experience!
The wednesday night wine dinner was sooooo good. from the appetizer to the dessert! What's not to like about a lobster dinner!
We were very disappointed with our meal last Wednesday. We ordered the wine and dine menu and the lobster was terrible. It was one quarter the size of a small lobster and it was dry. I can't believe this is a seafood restaurant. The appetizer was fine. We regularly dine at H2O but this may have been our last time. We all left feeling hungry.
Sunday Surf and Turf special for two at $68 is an excellent value, especially as it’s $90 the rest of the time. Well prepared and nicely served. I’ll be back.
The tile fish special of the day was deliciously prepared. Our waiter Ryan was delightful and had a great sense of humor. He was very attentive. We'll be back!
As usual our experience at H2O was outstanding! From the food to the popovers to our waiter, our entire group had a great time. Sitting in an enclosed booth helped keep the noise down! We will definitely be back soon!
Excellent food, the shrimp-lobster won ton appetizer was delicious. Our waiter and bus girl were very professional. Great experience. Will be back!!
We had the salmon as part of the wine and dine menu and it was absolutely the best we have ever had! Our waitress, Erica was fantastic. She spaced out the courses so we were able to enjoy the wine and she always stopped by the table to see how everything was going. The upside down apple cake was excellent!
Great meal. Gnocchi was awesome and so was the sushi.
Wife and I had an incredible dinner together
Lobsters were delicious as well as everything else. One of our favorite restaurants. Food & service are always 5 stars.
Always excellent food and service. Now they have this hook and cook deal where you catch the fish and they’ll cook it! We live it!!
The wine and dine menu was great! We loved all three courses paired with exquisite wines from Bedell Vineyards. The duck was really good and the salmon sushi appetizer was outstanding. Compliments to the chef!
Excellent dinner with friends. Sushi fantastic, great swordfish & drinks. Service great as always. Bartenders are always fun & attentive.
Everything was great at this wine tasting dinner . The wine pairings were terrific . Thanks for the champagne to celebrate our 24th Anniversary
The surf and turf wine dinner was excellent. The food was high quality and paired with outstanding wines from Red hook vineyard. We really enjoyed our dinner experience!
Absolutely wonderful birthday dinner! Couldn't have asked for anything more. Outstanding in every way.
Great experience and exceptional food