MIX Prime Steakhouse, Fish & Sushi Bar
My prime rib was terrible & tasteless. My daughter ordered the fish dish which was dry. We did not mention this to our waiter because he was excellent.
Restaurant was very busy and too noisy for my taste. Couldn’t hear the waitress telling us the specials. My steak was much too salty and my baked potato was not cooked through. The other diners in our group were satisfied with their choices, but nothing was exceptional. Wouldn’t go back.
Was great experience from start to finish. Charlie our waiter was wonderful.
First time eating here - food was great as well as the service. We will definitely be back!
Ryan was an amazing server. Knowledgeable and friendly. Food, as always, was delicious!!
Very disappointing visit this time.
Steak was overcooked and had to be sent back.
Brussels sprouts not charred but burned and had to be sent back.
Not sure what's going on but we will wait a bit before trying this again.
One of the best dinners ever! Food, service (Frank), ambiance were all fabulous. Great restaurant
Always good. My fave place for filet (w/cab sauce)
Sushi also excellent. Inside or out nice place to eat and drink
I’ve eaten at MIX Prime twice with equally very favorable reactions to the food and ambiance. We frequent many restaurants in Woodbury and had avoided MIX Prime as “too expensive”. But, we were wrong! We’ve had cocktails, wine, appetizers, soup, and entrees that we’re all wonderful and not cripplingly expensive.
They are now on our short list.
Lamb, hamburger, wings, onion soup, oysters... all memorably very good. Meats were cooked and served perfectly to our preference as ordered.
Don’t expect a quiet dining experience; it is a vibrant crowd clearly enjoying themselves. We ate in the “bar” and loved our waitress and the relative intimacy of our meal.
We’ve eaten in the dining room; it too was very close to perfect (I found the chairs to be very uncomfortable).
My wife and I look forward to our next visits to MIX Prime together or separately with friends.
Good sushi at a fair price, which is why I keep coming back. And my dining companion had what she deemed to be an excellent steak.
First time eating here, will come back. The French Onion Soup was one of the best we ever had. Just enough seasoning and cheese. We had the filet sandwich special and another filet dish with cut up beef in a sauce with risotto, so yummy.
Our group enjoyed a delicious dinner- we had a lovely evening.
It was thanksgiving and we never saw if there was any turkey. Deserts were very limited.
Waiter was very friendly and helpful. Overall slightly overpriced.
Mix Prime in Woodbury has become my favorite restaurant. The steaks and sushi are always great, service is attentive and not intrusive, and the bar is a great place to grab a quick drink or even have an improptu dinner. My one issue (and it't not just with Mix Prime) is that they don't seem to know how to deliver a rare steak with a nice exterior crust. You might get to medium rare or (worse!) medium. Still, the food is always flavorful. I have friends who come from across the state just to dine here. I definitely recommend it.
This was the first time we were seated in the dining room and we really enjoyed it. The ambience was lovely. We shared a house salad and it was tasty and large enough for two. My husband had the surf and turf special and was pleased. I had the shrimp scampi which was also delicious. Our only issue was that the food was served too quickly. We were still enjoying our cocktails when the salad arrived. We just finished our salads and the entrees were served. We prefer a more leisurely paced dinner, especially on a Saturday night when we want to relax after a busy week. We were in and out in an hour.
Shushi is as good as I’ve ever had and that includes the hundreds of sushi dinners I’ve had in Japan over 20 years of flying to Japan.
My wife had the haddock over broccoli rabe which was very tasty but completely overdone and at $40.00 way over priced.
Our only problem was that the main course was served to fast after the appetizer.
My husband and I were celebrating our Anniversary. We just moved from NY to Ct. We were very happy with our dining experience in Mix Prime. John, our waiter was so nice and friendly. He suggested the bone in Rib Eye Steak to my husband. The 24 ounce was plenty for us to share. I got the special filet mignon and lobster tail. It was excellent. We also had a dozen west coast oysters for appetizer. They were fresh and delicious. The meals came with one side each. We had the garlic mash potatoes and creamed spinach. The one serving was enough for both of us and we took steak and leftover sides home. The dessert special was pumpkin cheesecake and pumpkin gelato. The meal and dessert were delicious and the service from John was excellent! We will definitely return in the future!
This is a solid steak house with everything you'd look for...great steaks, classic sauces, sides, apps. Also exceptional sushi. Our server Frank was spot on with great service.
Excellent steak specially the bone in Rib eye. The side is super the. Mushroom and spinach.
The prime rib is amazing. Have it with creamy horseradish sauce. The filet was cooked perfectly, and the bearnaise sauce is excellent. Our server was attentive, but not hovering. The tiramasu was light and fluffy and perfect finish to the meal.
Wonderful food and service
Drinks made incorrectly. Steak tender and very good. Creamed Spinach mediocre. Deserts unimaginative. Service attentive.
Half our party had sushi and raved about it. The other had wonderful steak, prime rib and lobster....yum!
The service was good and the place has a friendly vibe. Definitely worth treating yourself , family and friends to a wonderful meal.
Vinny at the bar was great! Thank you for a nice afternoon.
We love mix prime and visit here when we want some great sushi. The salads are so fresh, the service is spot on and the place has a great atmosphere. We usually go late afternoon, before the rush of dinner guests arrive. It quiet and relaxing. Great place for a great meal.
This is our second time eating here since it was Max Prime. The menu is different. The steak was good, just not very flavorful. I wasn't wowed by this dinner. The other people with us were happy with their meals. I found it good but not delicious
I've been to Mix about 5 times since they opened. Service was better this time, but still leaves a lot to be desired. At these prices you expect your waiter to know if a chardonay is oaky or not. You also expect them to check on the table to see if they need a refill on drinks or anything for that matter- it doesn't count that the water guy comes to fill the glasses. The waiter should still check. It was a sunday night and they were not busy. Which is even MORE important that they be attentive. There is no excuse for it-again when you have the nerve to charge $30 for an entre you need to make sure your staff is trained properly and gives the appropriate message of what kind of restaurant this is.
All around great experience. From the time we were greeted at the door
until we finished our dinner.
Waiter was awesome, food and drinks amazing!
Waiter too busy trying to be entertaining and not being an attentive waiter
We probably should have stuck to the steak. The sushi was fishy and lacking freshness.
Chicken dish said boneless but it was not. Also quite dry. Steak was very good. So we’re the cocktails.
We enjoyed our meal and had a nice table in a relatively quiet location. Because the restaurant has so many hard surfaces, the noise level is always a bit high. We believe that the steaks are the best in the area.
Ambiance nice but it wasn’t crowded yet. I think it may get difficult to have a conversation across the large tables.
Food was very good.
My complaints: bread served was very plain as if it came from the local grocery store. Did not get replaced or offered more.
We were not told of or offered to hear what the specials of the evening were. I did hear them offered to the next table., after we had started eating our dinner.
Fun atmosphere! Great food! Try the grilled shrimp app! Special were all excellent!
This was our first time dining there. We enjoyed it very much and would certainly return when we are in the area which is about three or four times a year!
We found the food at MIX to be excellent, but they need to work on the front of the restaurant. Service was spotty at best. The server assigned to our table stumbled through the specials; we had to ask him to explain a couple of items several times. During the course of the meal, the server was reasonably attentive without being intrusive. However, I could never understand why the trend in restaurants today is for different people to take the order, deliver the food to the table, and clear the table. The person presenting the entrees wasn't sure who had ordered which dish (we were a party of four). At the end of the meal, our server disappeared; I didn't see him anywhere on the floor. He did not check in with us to see if we enjoyed our meal and would like anything else. A different person entirely presented me with the check. We must have waited at least 15 minutes following the clearing of the table for the check to arrive.
They were not busy when we had dinner. I ordered a filet with bernaise sauce. The filet came out first and the bernaise followed about 10 minutes later. They said they had to make it. Once it arrived it was missing a key ingredient so I had steak without bernaise.
We ordered a cocktail and a glass of wine. After 15 to 20 minutes I asked a busboy about status and he went over to the bar and picked our drinks up off the counter and brought them to us. We were 4 feet from the bar. Needless to say the drinks were sitting there quite awhile and almost all the ice had melted in my husband’s cocktail. Service might be better at the tables but was certainly lack luster at the sushi bar. I wouldn’t sit at the sushi bar again just due to poor service.
This was our first visit to Mix Prime and it won't be our last. We thoroughly enjoyed our visit. We all had the prime rib and it was excellent. Our waiter Charlie was very helpful and personable.