Not Your Average Joe's Peabody
Lassen Sie liefern
grilled meatloaf made with beef, pork, smoked mozzarella, veggies and herbs, with a tangy bbq gravy, mashed potatoes and herb-roasted carrots
Key Lime Pie
joe's mom's recipe, tart and refreshing with a cinnamon graham cracker crust, raspberry sauce and fresh whipped cream
Got grilled shrimp came with 2 sides. Everything was great tasting .
The food was great, the service was great
The shrimp tacos were delicious, as were the Nacho Average Nachos. First time trying watermelon iced tea, and it was amazing! Great ambiance and friendly, capable servers.
Our meal was great and the waiter was great. I was disappointed in the food I ordered to go. I ordered a meal to go and it was very small. Much smaller than regular portion. Very disappointed
I loved how quick I could get a reservation for 5 but the food was not great. Most of us did not finish the meal and did not take it home. The server was young, did not remove our dirty cups or plates from the table and did not offer refills on our drinks. We will not be returning.
Service was horrible: our waitress was impatient, we were told there was no bread shortly before other tables received theirs, we received our drinks after people at other tables who came afterwords had received their appetizers, the food arrived at room-temp and cooked incorrectly (a medium well order came medium rare, while a medium rare order came medium well). On top of that, one of our guests has a significant health issue and our waitress was drenched in a perfume that smelled like a car air freshener (specifically a Little Tree Strawberry), which caused him to need to put the cloth napkin against his face every time she was within 6 feet of the table.
We ordinarily have enjoyed good food and good service ever since NYAJ was in Beverly, but this time was just terrible, and our guest still cannot shake the odor. We're going to take a long break before we are able to get the courage to return.
Last minute decision to eat out so checked Open Table for a nearby restaurant. Not Your Average Joe’s popped up with availability. Made reservation and was promptly seated. Our server Dylan was excellent and gave extra attention to my wife’s food allergies. NYAJ always reliable choice for good food at reasonable price.
We received the level of quality, service and menu selection we’ve come to expect at NYAJ’s.
Vegetables were cold
Chicken was great
Stephen our waiter was awesome
Food was flavorless, buttermilk chicken sandwich had no flavor/seasoning at all
Jambalaya has no spice at all. Didn’t really care for a scoop of rice just plopped in the middle of the dish. Liked it much better when you used to serve it in a bowl.
Asked for more bread since the two pieces we got were as had as rock. We were told we ran out of bread, thank god for the oil that made it somewhat edible.
We did get more bread when I was ready to put my last folk full in my mouth.
Waitress was good.
The service was good and the food was amazing! I appreciated the attentive waitress and how quickly the food came out. The food was hot and delicious.
Great dinner with friends.
I was using my Birthday email from NYAJs, so the value was excellent
My wife had the Grilled Salmon (she always gets it) and it was bit disappointing this time .......the portion was smaller than usual and very thin which made it dry and crunchy.
I tried something different than usual.....the Spaghetti Squash Bolognese. It was ok, but little bland. Probably will go bake for the Haddock or Jumbolaya next time
Such a great time. They gave me free dessert for my birthday it was awesome! Thank you for everything.
Our server was very good and our salad with chicken was excellent.
Been a number of times before and loved NYAJ. TO IGHTS meal was only ok... scallops were dry as well as the risotto. The chickenPiccata was also dry and flavorless. Even the dipping oil was sub par... usually so delicious. We were disappointed with our experience tonight especially since it was a birthday celebration Our server was very nice but service was slow for a night tgat was not busy at all
Food delicious and never disappoints.
Server Kristen was exceptional!
Highly recommended ‼️
As always, we walk away discussing when we will go back to NYAJ's for their great food and service.
We sat in the bar area and had Kat as our server. Smiling at all times and delivering great service.
My husband had the great meatloaf with sautéed spinach and mashed potatoes to die for. I always put a twist on my order and had the rice bowl but substituted hoisin salmon for the shrimp and chicken. It was so good that I only ate half because I wanted to bring some home for later.
For the first time ever at a Not Your Average Joe’s, we were disappointed with the experience. I’m sure this was related to the fact that it was New Year’s Day, and the restaurant seemed a bit empty overall and probably had the B Team (or a hungover A Team) in the kitchen. But several of our dishes were undercooked and served cold. The salmon flatbread seemed to have been assembled by someone unacquainted with how to operate any of what I would assume are several food-heating devices available in the kitchen, or indeed with any form of food preparation. The potatoes served with the eggs benedict were interesting in that they appeared to be leftover from a previous day’s meal, but were still somehow not quite cooked.
The food at Not Your Average Joe's is very good. Six of us celebrated my husband's birthday. On the reservation at opentable I wrote that we were celebrating his birthday, but they didn't sing to him or give him a birthday dessert.
Food is always good. Cool atmosphere that is clean and fun. Ashley was a great server!
We’ve been here a few times since they opened, and the only thing that you can count on is that the food is just never good. The food is always overcooked or undercooked, something on the plate is always cold, the list goes on and on. We’ve never been able to get steak cooked correctly the first time, and the chicken has never once been anything other than underwhelming and done dry. We went there for my early birthday dinner with a party of 7, and nobody left happy. Seven people and not one person was satisfied with their meal. The staff is nice enough and the redesigned interior is nice, but it just doesn’t matter. We won’t come here again, even if it was free.
I informed my server that I had an allergy to peppers and asked her to check with the kitchen prior to placing my order. She did and verified that the item was safe for me to eat. Well, as the dinners were served to myself and 5 friends, I noticed red pepper flakes all over my meal. I asked server to send our waitress to the table. No waitress appearance but 5" late a manager appeared and said that there were no peppers in my meal but that the seasoning they used had red peppers. Seriously. I very clearly stated peppers allergy and OK meal did not have peppers but seasoning did...that does not make too much sense. They did offer to make another meal . I ordered something else and received my meal long after everyone else had finished eating. Not a great experience. They did remove the cost of my meal so yeah for that but honestly the money was not my concern. Respect food allergies or call it a day. I told the manager I would not return.
Enjoyed everything about our meal. Love the option for a 9oz glass of wine :)
Nice dinner after a movie.
Service was excellent. Salmon with mashed sweet potato and Brussels sprouts was cooked to perfection and a perfectly balanced combination of flavors and textures .
We came for my boyfriends birthday. The waiter was attentive and did well by surprising him with the birthday dessert. Overall we had a great time. The food was pretty good. My sons food was immensely dry. He got pasta and chicken tenders. But my fish and chips were great and my boyfriend loved his burger.
Great food and service.
Dylan in Peabody was awesome!!
We ate in the bar area and had the pleasure of Cat as our server. Cat was very warm and attentive and even remembered our "usual" orders.
I had the chicken shrimp bowl and substituted miso salmon for the protein. WOW perfection.
My husband ordered pizza ,HIS WAY. The crust is so good you eat the end pieces instead of leaving on your plate.
Bobby, the manager, came over to make sure that we were happy...which we were.
We'll be back
My husband and I went out to dinner to celebrate my birthday and I was disappointed you don’t have the gluten free scallops skewered with rosemary any longer.
Our server was mediocre at best. My favorite dish mustard crusted chicken was dry and tasteless. Freezer was broken so half the desserts were unavailable. Then our server proceeded to tell us they had no coffee because the shipment wasn’t coming until Tuesday (this was Saturday). A “manager” came to see how our meal was and said they did indeed have decaf coffee that he could brew. It arrived after I finished my dessert and was barely lukewarm. Not one offer to comp a coffee or dessert just a shrug of shoulders. I’ve always loved Not Your Average Joe’s, but this was an awful dinner from start to finish.
The food was very good as usual, The issue that we had was with the dessert. We ordered the Hot Fudge Sundae, Capaccino, and Tea. The waitress came back and told us that there was no ice cream, so we then ordered the Sorbet. The waitress gave us a plate of melted Sorbet and my coffee. She left the table quickly before I could say anything. We never got the Tea. Evidently there must have been an issue the freezer since no ice cream was available and the Sorbet was melted.
I realize that this was an off incident, but it will be a while before we return to Not your Average Joe's again.
Amanda b in Peabody was great
Mashed potatoes were cold though
Today we decided to order something besides our "usual".
Amanda, our favorite server, highly recommended the freshly made meatloaf.
It was better than my deceased mothers. We ordered it with sautéed spinach and mashed potatoes.
It's our new favorite.
Thank you Amanda for the recommendation and great service.
We have eaten here in the past. Food was not as good this time so it was a little disappointing. Not sure if we will be back.
the mustard chicken is a staple at NYAJ's for a good reason. It is wonderful and hard to duplicate. Pair that with their outrageous mashed potatoes and sautéed spinach and you have a real winner.
Then, when Amanda, our favorite server, brings it over with a big smile you have a perfect meal.
Poor Service, Poor Food Quality.
I will not be back
NYAJ's is always great. Amanda, the manager, makes sure that everything is running smoothly at all times.
Our waiter Tyler, was a warm, professional server.
My husband and I mix and match menus items and the kitchen delivers our request perfectly.
We order the chicken and shrimp bowl with the miso salmon, in place of the chicken and shrimp.
Not Your Average Joe's Peabody wird von 344 OpenTable‑Gästen mit 4.2 Sternen bewertet.
Reservieren Sie in diesem Restaurant, indem Sie Datum, Uhrzeit und Personenzahl wählen.