Old Angler's Inn
Can't Beat Our Happy Hour!
Enjoy 1/2 price on select food and 25% all other food items on bar menu! Thirsty? 25% off all rail liquor, beers and house wines!
Available at the Bar and select seating. Bring Friends!
Gültig für: 1 - 20 Personen
Beginn: 10. Oktober 2019
Ende: 11. Oktober 2118
Verfügbarkeit: Mo.-Fr. 16:30-18:30
It's a terrific spot; especially nice with fire going outside but the downstairs' ambience really outweighs the upstairs. Upstairs is nice but in the winter, I would think the downstairs would be in demand. Service was a little slow but all and all a very nice experience.
The food and service were excellent. We were a little disappointed that they sat us upstairs which was nice but didn’t quite have the ambiance of the downstairs with the fireplace. Also the spiral staircase to the upstairs was narrow and definitely not for anybody with mobility issues. Next time, we’ll request a table downstairs.
It was my first time there, it was very very classy, beautiful both inside and out. The server was very attentive and professional. I had a Groupon and I’ll definitely be returning
Our second visit - again very enjoyable. The ahi salad, the trout dip, the creme brûlée - all superb. The cauliflower mac and cheese was fine, just not special.
Definitely recommend! Service started out pretty slow but got better through the meal. Love this place!
After valet car service we walked up to a roaring outdoor fire. It was beautiful.
Entered the Inn and another fire kept the room cozy and inviting.
Excellent service, delicious fish—salmon and swordfish. Great cocktails —it was truly a wonderful evening in a special place.
Spectacular food, great ambiance(sitting by the fire ) and attentive service
Perfect setting by the Outdoor Fire Pit, food excellent and our server attentive and could ask for better. Thank you
Excellent service and place
Outstanding ambiance. Food was good but not particularly inspiring. A better place for drinks than for a special occasion meal, but for the ambiance.
I had the rack of lamb and my boyfriend had the hamburger with foie gras. We also split a Caesar salad and surf and turf appetizer. The meals were great and the staff was very friendly and accommodating. Given that the meals are relatively expensive and the venue is historic, I would recommend different music besides disco. Other than that it was a very enjoyable experience.
The food is excellent and the atmosphere is cozy. We were meeting up with old friends from Europe and were looking forward to a relaxing dinner to catch up. I made reservations a day in advance and requested a table by the fireplace, which didn't happen. We were still enjoying our appetizers, when our entree arrived and the waiter without asking just took away my appetizer that I was still eating! Felt very rushed even though the restaurant didn't seem super busy.
I love the downstairs in the winter; the fireplace makes it a delight!
Bar often seems disorganized, unprepared and drinks are slow to arrive.
My husband’s birthday
Went for lunch. Great location to combine hiking with a nice reward. Wine prices ridiculous which is why only 4 stars.
Pretty relax atmosphere, and the dishes are right on par.
We enjoyed our dinner. From the French onion soup to the seafood pasta and the salmon entree, everything was delicious. Thanks for a lovely evening.
We returned to OAI to celebrate our son’s 18th birthday, and the staff did not disappoint. The service and food were outstanding. Highly recommended!
Old Anglers is the perfect spot for a post hike/post paddle meal. It's super cozy and relaxing. The food is "fine" and the wine is good.
Seems a little confusing. Are they fine dining or upper casual? I suspect the latter. We had 4 people, 5 if you include the bartender, yet serviced seemed very slow and inattentive. No one ever came back to see how our meal tasted after it was served. Also, our original waiter simply disappeared after giving us our drinks.
French toast only included 2 pieces of the type of bread advertised and sausage was so so. I had the Reuben which was not too bad but on the edge of being rubbery.
All in all a decent place but keep expectations on the low end.
Overpriced, in my estimation. Lunch for 2 was $75. Felt like a lot for what we got.
Wonderful ambience, service, and cuisine. A real treasure.
Very friendly service. Delicious food. Two staff members from Albania were both very polite and with sense of humor. They came to see us often and complemented the service of our waiter. All was perfect.
We will for sure come back again.
Seafood was delicious, beautiful decor inside and out, great live music in 2 areas, awesome service.
The service was outstanding. We never felt rushed and when we told the server that we weren't ready, she didn't forget about us.
The food was excellent. I had the crab cake and shared with my husband who had the mussels. The crab cake was delicious and served with a delicious corn relish. The mussels were good, but a little on the small side. We also enjoyed brussel sprouts. One of our friends had the salmon and he was very happy with it. Our other friend had the mussels and she, too, thought they were a little small. But they were tasty!
I like the atmosphere, charming old home with lots of interesting history.
We look forward to returning.
OAI is a constant go to place. When we go there with friends they are always impressed by the place, the service and the food. You can't go wrong on a beautiful day eating outside and the inside is warm and inviting.
Excellent food, service, ambience and overall experience. The $$ rating is misleading. This menu is very good but very expensive. That needs to be reflected on the reviews.
We had a coupon for this restaurant, now I see why they have resorted to groupons. We have dined here before and it was good, but this time a red haired waitress that was better suited to Chili’s served us. The food was not worth eating, and even the ambience was destroyed by bright lighting in the upstairs room. More like a cafeteria than a fine dining restaurant which they think they are.
Not going back.
Always delightful and delicious. I will return in the near future.
Excellent service and food was very good. I had the rockfish special husband had the chicken. All cooked perfectly and not over sauced or too much butter. Would have given 5 stars but felt it was a tad overpriced and would have liked the indoor fireplace lit. But overall pleasantly surprised. The service really made the difference.
I wa hoping that this would be better than the worst of the reviews...It wasn’t. At 7:30 on a Saturday evening, it was pretty busy. With that said, the waitress had about 15 tables sat, and it went downhill from there. The oysters were tasty, and came out within 20 min. The main course followed about an hour later, and the lamb was cold. The crab cake my date had, tasted previously frozen. The lamb was just ok, definitely not worth the $40+ they command for a dish. The brussel sprouts were entirely inedible, being undercooked. Our waitress was nice enough to comp our bill by 50 percent, sensing that the evening hadn’t gone too well. Wouldn’t recommend.
My sister and my 2 sons dined at Old Angler's Inn on Saturday night. It was amazing! The food and the service was 2nd to none and we thoroughly loved this hidden gem. We will definitely recommend this to our friends and look forward to returning.
Lovely venue. The lamb chops and scallops were terrific. The server was attentive, although the kitchen was a bit overwhelmed for some reason the night we went and entrees were a bit slow to arrive. The outdoor seating area is so pleasant. We opted for an inside table on this cool autumn evening, though they have heaters out there. Charming spot and great food.
Dinner was great. Noted on reservation that it was our anniversary. They made no mention.
Friday lunch on a day the weather was Marvelous! Restaurant was crowded for outside seating, a little bit overwhelming for the servers, as there was no hostess, and few bussers. Service was slow but we had nothing pressing, so we were patient. Once service began, it was quick, efficient and the food was, as usual, perfection.
It is a very nice setting and eating outside is always a pleasure for me. I think the restaurant needs some updating as most of the patrons are older like myself and the menu is pricy. I would hate to see such a nice spot for dinner close because of a downturn in clients.
My friend asked for a table out of the sun, but by 15 minutes into our lunch, we were in full sun — and blinking to see one another. A lovely place, the inn needs to elevate the quality of its food. My hamburger was far from the rare that I had requested, but my companion’s Eggs Benedict were perfect, in her words. All in all, I always enjoy the inn, but am disappointed in its offerings.
I love the ambiance at Old Angler’s Inn. But on this occasion, service was unbearably slow. Also: avoid their burgers: they appear to be made from frozen meat - inexcusable for a restaurant of this stature (and price).
Fantastic as we remembered. Wonderful spot and excellent food/service for our 30th anniversary.