Old Homestead Steakhouse- New York City

4.4
3524 Bewertungen
51 USD und darüber
Steakhaus

Top-Etiketten:

Besondere Anlässe
Gut für Jahrestage
Für Rendezvous geeignet
Das Old Homestead Steakhouse aus dem Jahr 1868 erwartet Sie im ultraschicken Viertel Meat Packing District. Das Restaurant unterhält enge Beziehungen zu seinen Metzgern, sodass Sie nur das beste Rindfleisch genießen. Nichts als Prime Dry Aged-Fleisch - das war schon immer so, und so wird es immer bleiben. Das Restaurant ist Gewinner des Wine Spectator Awards 2006. Freuen Sie sich zudem auf Hummer mit einem Gewicht von 1,8 bis 5,9 kg, Thunfisch in Sushi-Qualität, Rotlachs, Colossal-Krabbenfleisch und Garnelen, die so groß sind, dass sie als kleine Bananen bezeichnet werden.

Sicherheitsmaßnahmen

Reinigung und Desinfektion
  • Desinfektion von Oberflächen nach jedem Gast
  • Digitales, desinfiziertes oder Einweg-Menü
  • Desinfektionsmittel oder Reinigungstücher für Kunden
Räumliche Distanz
  • Begrenzte Anzahl sitzender Gäste
  • Abstandhalten in gemeinschaftlichen Bereichen
  • Zusätzlicher Platz zwischen den Tischen
Schutzausrüstung
  • Servicepersonal trägt Mundschutz
Screening
  • Krankes Personal am Arbeitsplatz verboten
Was 3524 Gäste sagen
Bewertungen insgesamt
Bewertungen können nur von Gästen gemacht werden, die in diesem Restaurant gegessen haben.
4.4Basierend auf kürzlich erfolgten Ratings
4.4
Essen
4.3
Service
4.2
Ambiente
4.0
Preis-Leistung
Lärm · Gemäßigt
84 % der Gäste würden das Restaurant einem Freund empfehlen
Sortieren nach
Filter
ML
MichelleL
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 12. Dezember 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Worth every penny. Absolutely no complaints. Wonderful place to impress.

Melden
AL
AmyL
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 12. Dezember 2020
Gesamt1Essen2Service1Ambiente1

Don't bother with this place - there are so many superior steakhouses in NYC. I knew we were in for trouble when the waiter delivered my blue cheese martini, he plopped it down and said "we're out of blue cheese". I told him that I wished he would have told me that before bringing it to me, to which he declared that he just found out before walking away from the table. Steak was decent, Lobster mac and cheese was way too fishy (i know lobster comes from the ocean but it tasted like tit hung out there a few extra days after it died). Ask for the bread basket or you wont get one. And to cap off this experience the waiter must have seen me sign the bill because he immediately came over and reached over the table to grab it even though my hand was still resting on it.

Melden
S
vipSportsgirl
Raum New York
106 Bewertungen
Besucht am 11. Dezember 2020
Gesamt4Essen5Service5Ambiente4

Excellent service and very good, although pricey steakhouse fare.

Melden
a
vipangelap
Raum New York
2 Bewertungen
Besucht am 10. Dezember 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente3

Anniversary

Melden
EN
EricNYC
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 10. Dezember 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente4

If you are looking for outdoor seating with heaters that work OId Homestead has the heat and the steaks! Excellent service - food was terrific. Go Here! They even had sanitizer on the table. Delicious!

Melden
ET
EricT
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 6. Dezember 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Highly recommended great service great food.........

Melden
DC
DaisyC
Atlantic City
9 Bewertungen
Besucht am 6. Dezember 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente4

Great experience

Melden
AW
AriW
Milwaukee
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 5. Dezember 2020
Gesamt4Essen3Service3Ambiente4

Ambience outdoors was nice with the three walled space, though heaters were not strong. String lights were a cute touch. We ordered the ribeye for two, creamed spinach and fries. The ribeye, while cooked to a perfect temperature, was under seasoned. The fries came out soft and without any salt. I was happy to support local and go for a fine dining meal, but was underwhelmed.

Melden
D
vipDerek
Raum New York
12 Bewertungen
Besucht am 4. Dezember 2020
Gesamt4Essen4Service4Ambiente4

Steak was surprisingly excellent and tender. Caesar was average.

Melden
m
vipmichaelw
Raum New York
2 Bewertungen
Besucht am 26. November 2020
Gesamt3Essen4Service1Ambiente3

Food outstanding as always.
The service was terribly slow.
It was 40 minutes before we got our appetizers and then another 25 minute wait for the main course.
Usually Old Homestead is fantastic, which is why we went there
Very disappointed
Food was great though

Melden
OT
OpenTable-Gast
Raum New York
2 Bewertungen
Besucht am 26. November 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

An old favorite the Old Homestead did not disappoint for a socially distanced Thanksgiving lunch. Great food and service. Love this place. Thanks team. Great job.

Melden
LR
LorieR
Chicago
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 26. November 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Can’t beat a $70 pre fixe for thanksgiving at a steak house in NYC. Had a great time

Melden
EF
ErnieF
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 22. November 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

I felt safe while dining. All the proper precautions were take . As long as the tables are spaced out and there is limited contact, I think you guys have a great setup. Thanks for the experience!!!

Melden
S
Sonja
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 20. November 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Porterhouse steak is amazing, highly recommended. Excellent wine selection too.

Melden
OT
OpenTable-Gast
Raum New York
3 Bewertungen
Besucht am 18. November 2020
Gesamt3Essen3Service3Ambiente2

Not first time however first time since 2020 began. Having said that won’t be rushing back. Meal was fine nothing over the top, good cuts of meat prepared to liking. A little too crowded. Spacing definitely not ideal for current climate.

Melden
CP
CharlesP
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 17. November 2020
Gesamt4Essen4Service3Ambiente4

Average steakhouse. Food is well prepared and the wait between courses was reasonable. Had to wait awhile to receive the desert menu only to find that the ipad tablet used to show the menu wasn't working. The waiter could have just as easily told us the deserts options, which are limited, instead of making us wait for the desert menu.

Melden
OT
OpenTable-Gast
Raum New York
2 Bewertungen
Besucht am 15. November 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Everything was great as always

Melden
P
Phillip
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 13. November 2020
Gesamt1Essen1Service3Ambiente1

I’ve lived in the city all my life, I’ve heard such great things of this steakhouse, and their Kobe Beef burger was the cherry on the sundae.

It wasn’t what I expected, this place is out dated, the Kobe beef burger was dry, it was cooked at a medium.

The ribeye for two lacked flavor and was just charred.

The crispy calamari was soggy.

The waiter staff is out of touch with the customer, they gave off a misogynist vibe. It was very unwelcoming and very off putting.

Honestly I’m disappointed in this establishment.

It’s turned into a tourist attraction like Peter Lugers, but Peter Lugers tastes decent.

Melden
S
Suzy
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 13. November 2020
Gesamt1Essen3Service5Ambiente3

They practice no social distancing- every table was packed.

Melden
OT
OpenTable-Gast
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 12. November 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Very nice,very professional and hospitable. I would always recommend old homestead

Melden
ST
vipSTEPHENM
Raum New York
72 Bewertungen
Besucht am 6. November 2020
Gesamt5Essen4Service4Ambiente4

Classic steakhouse. Excellent, well-prepared entrees and appetizers. Signature porterhouse for two done to perfection-medium rare. Excellent covid-conscioousness with appropriate distancing, masks and sanitizers. HIGHLY recommended.

Melden
D
David
Raum New York
4 Bewertungen
Besucht am 31. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

I went for the 6oz waygu. Going in, I was concerned it would be overhyped...not worth the $200 tag. The presentation was underwhelming, meat and vegetables. When I actually had it...it was unbelievably delicious. The best steak I’ve tasted. I can’t say if it’s worth the money, but for a special occasion, you’re going to an iconic NYC steakhouse having a once in a lifetime experience.

Melden
NM
vipNancyM
Raum New York
6 Bewertungen
Besucht am 31. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

It's always a pleasure seeing everyone. Great food, drinks and atmosphere.

Melden
OT
OpenTable-Gast
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 30. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

I went to dine at Old Homestead Steakhouse for my boyfriends birthday. The food and wine was amazing. The atmosphere was wonderful, the staff were very welcoming and nice. I noticed that the waiters helped each other out! Each waiter that passed by asked if everything was ok although they were not our main waiter.
Definitely recommend this restaurant.

Melden
OT
vipOpenTable-Gast
Raum New York
8 Bewertungen
Besucht am 30. Oktober 2020
Gesamt3Essen2Service5Ambiente4

Under seasoned... disappointing... the waygu was mediocre

Melden
OT
OpenTable-Gast
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 30. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

I'm vegetarian and they go above and beyond. Service is impeccable. Meat eating companions love the steak.

Melden
GF
vipGiovanniF
Raum New York
8 Bewertungen
Besucht am 30. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

The bone in rib-eye is the best steak in town. Great place to celebrate a special occasion.

Melden
OT
OpenTable-Gast
Raum New York
6 Bewertungen
Besucht am 28. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Great service. Filet was amazing. Good vibes.

Melden
EK
vipExactoKnife
Raum New York
60 Bewertungen
Besucht am 27. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente4

Dined recently (10/27). Structured, protected outdoor seating available. We elected to dine inside. Covid safe protocols in place. Socially distanced tables. Temperature check upon arrival. Hand sanitizer provided on arrival. Masks required until you are seated at your table. All staff wear mask and gloves. Most importantly, the food and service were excellent. A classic on the MPD.

Melden
CP
CarlaP
Raum New York
8 Bewertungen
Besucht am 24. Oktober 2020
Gesamt1Essen1Service3Ambiente2

Very disappointed not sure if they are catching up after been closed due to COVID but the food was terrible and I have eaten there many times. Food was rushed steak burnt and dry very disappointed not worth the exorbitant prices.

Melden
VR
VeronicaR
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 24. Oktober 2020
Gesamt4Essen5Service3Ambiente4

Excellent food quality! The heaters outdoors were very pleasant. Great lively music and ambiance. Drinks were not listed on any menu and turned out be very expensive for a house wine, a bit sneaky, but no complaints whatsoever about the food. Delicious!

Melden
OT
OpenTable-Gast
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 23. Oktober 2020
Gesamt2Essen5Service3Ambiente2

Anniversary

Melden
S
Shirley
Raum New York
3 Bewertungen
Besucht am 20. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente4

Attentive staff. Perfect steak- porterhouse for 2.

Melden
VF
VincentF
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 20. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente3

We did the outside dinner thing which was nice but would have chosen to do inside if we were to do it over. Food always excellent but a bit pricy, get what you pay for though. Service was great, very argentine to your needs and can read their guests personalities well. They treat you like Royalty. Be prepared to eat when going here!!

Melden
OT
vipOpenTable-Gast
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 17. Oktober 2020
Gesamt2Essen2Service4Ambiente1

Too many obnoxious patrons making lots of noise. Will never go back

Melden
OT
vipOpenTable-Gast
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 17. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Amazing experience. Incredible food & remarkable service. Delicious martinis (with blue cheese stuffed olives). Wedge & ceaser salad were great, along with the Gotham & ribeye steaks. Shoutout to George.

Melden
OT
vipOpenTable-Gast
Raum New York
3 Bewertungen
Besucht am 17. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Such a fun satisfying dinner evening out!

Melden
OT
OpenTable-Gast
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 11. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Great experience

Melden
RM
vipRobertM
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 9. Oktober 2020
Gesamt2Essen3Service1Ambiente4

Chef’s Bread & appetizers were excellent. Entrees were mediocre at best, ordered my steak medium, it was well done. My friends shrimp scampi was over cooked & inedible. Waiter could care less we were there. I generally tip well over 30%, first time I tipped around 17% in 25 years.

Melden
T
Tiff
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 3. Oktober 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

The venue was super accommodating. The staff was very professional & welcoming. Our waiter catered to our every need. The meals were delectable. Definitely will recommend & will be returning

T

Melden

FAQ

Old Homestead Steakhouse- New York City bietet Lieferungen in Partnerschaft mit Uber Eats an.

Old Homestead Steakhouse- New York City wird von 3524 OpenTable‑Gästen mit 4.4 Sternen bewertet.

Ja, Sie können üblicherweise in diesem Restaurant reservieren, indem Sie auf OpenTable Datum, Uhrzeit und Personenzahl wählen. Aufgrund lokaler Einschränkungen nimmt dieses Restaurant derzeit möglicherweise keine Reservierungen entgegen.