Pizza Secret

Sortieren nach

Filter

1. OT

   OpenTable Diner

   Raum New York

   4 Bewertungen

   4.0

   4 Bewertungen

   Vor 6 Tagen besucht

   overall4food4service4ambience4

   Neapolitan pizzas, salads, and beverages in pleasant setting, with kind, professional service.

   Report
2. DN

   DawnNYC

   Raum New York

   86 Bewertungen

   VIP
   3.0

   86 Bewertungen

   Besucht am 1. Juni 2022

   overall3food3service3ambience4

   Our server was friendly but inexperienced. Even though she served it in a plain glass on ice and we ordered “club soda,” she charged $5.00 for a Pellegrino on the bill and never showed the bottle to the table. Found out at home. Twice, we politely asked “Coleen” to confirm our OpenTable table—she never did. Arancini was fine. Pizza was a disappointment. The middle was soupy, thin, and completely fell apart whether we ate it with a knife and fork, or not. Octopus dish was one lone tentacle in a plateful of salad. Chef can just make it an insalata on the menu then. Tasty tentacle. Margaritas were nice. Convenient corner location.

   Report
3. JM

   JaneM

   1 Bewertung

   5.0

   1 Bewertung

   Besucht am 21. Mai 2022

   overall5food5service5ambience5

   Food was delicious, staff were superb and location was excellent.

   Report
4. EA

   ElenaAM

   Raum New York

   14 Bewertungen

   VIP
   4.0

   14 Bewertungen

   Besucht am 26. März 2022

   overall4food4service5ambience4

   Came here for brunch on Saturday. I am Italian and I LOVED that they were playing all the newest hits from Sanremo! It felt like being back home for a bit. The pizzas are good, the Tiramisù is OK, and they have cocktails! I just found it a little weird that we were the only customers on a Saturday at 12:30. It gives a weird vibe when a restaurant is empty!

   Report
5. T

   Tina

   Raum New York

   11 Bewertungen

   VIP
   5.0

   11 Bewertungen

   Besucht am 24. März 2022

   overall5food5service5ambience5

   Had dinner here before seeing a show at Barclay’s Center. Pizza was absolutely amazing—we shared the American pizza with pepperoni and hot honey, the pizza with Arugula and prosciutto and the mushroom truffle pizza—all were incredibly delicious and we couldn’t decide on a favorite. Highly recommend and will definitely be back!

   Report
6. LD

   LyndaD

   Los Angeles

   70 Bewertungen

   VIP
   5.0

   70 Bewertungen

   Besucht am 15. März 2022

   overall5food5service5ambience5

   Incredible pizza and great staff/owner. High quality ingredients executed flawlessly. We kept thinking about the pizza days after!

   Report
7. RD

   RachelD

   Minneapolis

   15 Bewertungen

   5.0

   15 Bewertungen

   Besucht am 1. März 2022

   overall5food5service5ambience5

   Drinks were very good. The salad was very fresh and tasty. The pizza was fantastic, we really liked the crisp yet chewy, delicious crust!

   Report
8. JS

   JenniS

   1 Bewertung

   3.0

   1 Bewertung

   Besucht am 20. Februar 2022

   overall3food3service4ambience4

   Okay, not great. Wasn’t super hot and crust in the center was wet versus a bit crisp.

   Report
9. OT

   OpenTable Diner

   Raum New York

   2 Bewertungen

   5.0

   2 Bewertungen

   Besucht am 11. Februar 2022

   overall5food5service5ambience5

   Pizza secret is the best, easy and low key but with high quality food and service. We met friends for dinner and had babies with us, the entire staff was so wonderful and helpful. We had a great time.

   Report
10. AR

    AntonioR

    Raum New York

    3 Bewertungen

    5.0

    3 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 18. September 2021

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    Food was delicious- I especially loved the Misticanza salad. The lasagna and the pasta we had was great as well. The young woman who served us was especially gracious and attentive. Great dining experience although my companion was surprised that bread was not served before the meal. But he loved his meal!

    Report
11. OT

    OpenTable Diner

    Raum New York

    1 Bewertung

    5.0

    1 Bewertung

    Besucht am 27. August 2021

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    Our Friday night out at Pizza Secret was magnificent! Service was quick and efficient. Food was amazing. Drinks were incredible! (I HIGHLY recommend the Baileys espresso martini) just an overall amazing experience. Will be returning to this cute little spot. :)

    Report
12. L

    Lpmommy

    Raum New York

    12 Bewertungen

    4.0

    12 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 15. Juni 2021

    overall4food5service4ambience4

    The food was amazing!!

    Report
13. K

    Katharina

    Raum New York

    3 Bewertungen

    5.0

    3 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 3. Mai 2021

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    I’ve been to Rosario’s pizza place several times and it’s always a delight! The place is wonderful and Rosario and his team put their heart and soul into preparing the food. Which is absolutely delicious. The atmosphere is great: the subtle background music makes you feel like you’re in Naples... one of Brooklyn’s best kept secret! 😃

    Report
14. SG

    StephanieG

    Raum New York

    1 Bewertung

    5.0

    1 Bewertung

    Besucht am 16. April 2021

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    Food is amazing and ambiance is great ! Would definitely recommend !

    Report
15. V

    Valery

    Raum New York

    4 Bewertungen

    5.0

    4 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 9. April 2021

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    As always they delivered! A wonderful experience with wonderful, attentive and engaging staff.

    Report
16. YT

    YosefT

    Raum New York

    15 Bewertungen

    VIP
    5.0

    15 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 1. April 2021

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    Great food, cute interior, fair prices and great music. Would love to come back again

    Report
17. TK

    TK719

    Raum New York

    440 Bewertungen

    VIP
    5.0

    440 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 30. März 2021

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    Wow - best pizza that I've ever eaten! The dough is simply out of this world. The tomato sauce and veggies were also fantastic. I started with a wonderful kale and pear salad. I finished with the fried dough covered with nutella. Great service and great prices. Also very close the subway. I can't wait to go back!

    Report
18. V

    Valery

    Raum New York

    4 Bewertungen

    5.0

    4 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 20. März 2021

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    The staff is amazing and extremely welcoming! The food was tasty and presentation was well though out. The music was fantastic. If you’re looking for an authentic Italian food experience this it! Thank you for making our birthday celebration one to remember!

    Report
19. AP

    AndreaP

    Raum New York

    1 Bewertung

    5.0

    1 Bewertung

    Besucht am 14. Februar 2021

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    One of the top Italian restaurants in Brooklyn! Ask for a vegan calzone, you won't regret it!

    Report
20. FC

    FedericoC

    Raum New York

    7 Bewertungen

    VIP
    5.0

    7 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 8. November 2020

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    Eat pizza at Rosario’s restaurant is like going back in the days, eating Sunday evening pizza in Italy with my family or friends. If you are looking for the real Traditional Italian pizza, this is the place. There are many Italian pizzerias in NYC, but no one gave me back the exclusive Italian taste at every bite like Secret Pizza.

    Report
21. OT

    OpenTable Diner

    Raum New York

    1 Bewertung

    5.0

    1 Bewertung

    Besucht am 24. Oktober 2020

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    Friendly and honest taste. Perfect dough

    Report
22. T

    Tara

    Raum New York

    39 Bewertungen

    VIP
    5.0

    39 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 12. September 2020

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    Authentic Naples style Pizza! Everything was amazing, looking forward to going back.

    Report
23. KS

    KimberlyS

    Raum New York

    32 Bewertungen

    VIP
    5.0

    32 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 6. September 2020

    overall5food5service5ambience3

    Super authentic- Best Neapolitan pizza in Brooklyn!

    Report
24. OT

    OpenTable Diner

    Raum New York

    2 Bewertungen

    5.0

    2 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 1. September 2020

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    The most amazing pizza! Very authentic!

    Report
25. OT

    OpenTable Diner

    Neuengland

    1 Bewertung

    2.0

    1 Bewertung

    Besucht am 8. März 2020

    overall2food2service3ambience2

    The food was cold, restaurant was obnoxiously loud and the prices were high. Better Italian and pizza joints all over Brooklyn as both quality and value. Yelp rating is very misleading

    Report
26. AH

    AislingH

    Raum New York

    3 Bewertungen

    3.0

    3 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 29. Februar 2020

    overall3food4service2ambience2

    Excellent Food. We came here before a concert at Barclays. It was freezing that day so I think they were a bit overwhelmed with all the people rushing in to get out of the cold. We had a reservation and were seated on time. The pizza came out before our appetizers which I thought was odd but was told by the server "it's always this way". All the food was very good. We had to continue to flag down a server when we needed things but it was never hard to find him. It was an OK experience. I would maybe go back if I'm craving pizza before another Barclays show.

    Report
27. SA

    SusanA

    Raum New York

    4 Bewertungen

    5.0

    4 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 19. Februar 2020

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    Delicious pizza. Gnocchi in tomato sauce very satisfying. Yummy tiramisu. Very helpful waiter who made a good wine suggestion.

    Report
28. OT

    OpenTable Diner

    Philadelphia

    1 Bewertung

    VIP
    1.0

    1 Bewertung

    Besucht am 15. Februar 2020

    overall1food2service2ambience1

    Absolutely mobbed inside. 4 different groups had reservations at the same time waiting at the door. Waiters did everything they could, however could of used more help for the amount of people they were serving. Seated basically at the door where 10-12 people hovering over waiting to be seated. Couldn’t take coats off because it was too cold from door opening. Never got water. The real issue was watching the owners provide absolutely zero help to the staff. They just simply watched the chaos ensue and didn’t provide assistance. Shoutout to the one waiter/hostess/bartender for running the show. The owners need to lend a hand instead of just smile and watch.

    Report
29. TB

    TacoBoutIt

    Raum New York

    4 Bewertungen

    1.0

    4 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 2. November 2019

    overall1food4service1ambience1

    I have been before and loved the food, so I made a 6:45 reservation for 3 people on a Saturday with a note that we had an 8:00 show at Barclays. By 6:12 I knew we were running a bit late so I modified it to 7pm. No one was at the host stand, the place was packed, and I was standing nearly outside. No one came to check until 7:01, and by then there were people behind me waiting for their 7pm reservation as well, a table of 6. I wasn’t asked my name, and the owner just said, “People are finishing up.” By 7:17 all of the people outside and myself still hadn’t been seated. A family of 4 without a reservation was told, “5-10 minutes” before I got there, but eventually gave up. I did as well, as I knew I wouldn’t make my show in time with such slow service. When small places are busy, you should decline walk-ins or say, “We need the table back by 6:50.” I’m glad business is booming, but they need to figure out the reservation system.

    Report
30. OT

    OpenTable Diner

    Raum New York

    2 Bewertungen

    VIP
    5.0

    2 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 26. Oktober 2019

    overall5food5service4ambience5

    Always a great true Neapolitan pizza

    Report
31. OT

    OpenTable Diner

    Raum New York

    2 Bewertungen

    VIP
    5.0

    2 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 5. Oktober 2019

    overall5food5service4ambience5

    Great Pizza, perfect Neapolitan style. Strongly advised

    Report
32. BF

    BrooklynFoodie

    London

    13 Bewertungen

    VIP
    5.0

    13 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 13. September 2019

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    I celebrated my sons birthday with 5 10-year-olds and their parents and Pizza Secret was very accommodating to our large party and made us feel special on his birthday. The food was excellent and a good value for money. I would definitely go again.

    Report
33. SK

    ScottK

    Raum New York

    41 Bewertungen

    VIP
    3.0

    41 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 17. August 2019

    overall3food4service2ambience3

    This place is weird. The food is delicious. The service sucks. Mixed together and you get a solid 2.5 stars.

    Report
34. JC

    JeremiahC

    Raum New York

    2 Bewertungen

    1.0

    2 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 1. August 2019

    overall1food1service1ambience1

    Extremely uninspiring food and less-than-ideal service marked the experience at Pizza Secret. Everything about the restaurant exuded an “amateur hour” feel. The restaurant was not particularly full but yet receiving menus and food items took a very long time. Two members of our party got their pasta dishes long before the salad appetizer arrived. The kale salad was supposed to have cranberries in it but did not come with any (the waiter only offered that they ran out of the cranberries when asked directly). It also did not have any dressing and was extremely dry, only with barely perceptible lemon juice. The salad was painful. Two pizzas were in our order: a Bufala and a Margherita, each with toppings. Both arrived with extremely thin middle sections that were completely soggy and limp. Mozzarella cheese and other toppings easily rolled right off the pies, and it made the most sense to eat the pizza with a knife and fork. The best part of the meal for me was getting the check so we could leave. I live in the neighborhood and had never heard of Pizza Secret before. This was our first and only visit, and I wish it had remained a secret.

    Report
35. T

    Terryd

    Raum New York

    11 Bewertungen

    VIP
    5.0

    11 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 7. Juli 2019

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    I really stand behind my 5-stars for here. The pizza is beyond excellent and the staff are always accommodating and professional. Large tables are great for groups, they are incredibly family friendly yet have great wines and drinks. What’s not to like? Outside the name... really needs a better name.

    Report
36. OR

    ORDtoLGA

    Chicago

    8 Bewertungen

    VIP
    5.0

    8 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 15. Juni 2019

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    Pizza Secret is excellent!! It is a beautiful chic breezy place with authentic food and staff. Our food came so fast and it was delicious! I loved every minute of being there. Will definitely return!

    Report
37. AS

    AmyS

    Neuengland

    1 Bewertung

    1.0

    1 Bewertung

    Besucht am 17. Mai 2019

    overall1food1service1ambience2

    The service was terrible. The food was just not good. We left before they even brought one of the entrees

    Report
38. JB

    JosephB

    Raum New York

    6 Bewertungen

    VIP
    5.0

    6 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 11. März 2019

    overall5food5service5ambience5

    Pizza Secret could be one of the best restaurants in the 5 boroughs. First of all, the pizza is exceptional. If you’re a fan of authentic, brick oven Neapolitan pizza, this is the place for you. The ingredients are fresh. The pizza is made promptly. The taste is outstanding. The quality of service at Pizza Secret only enhances the dining experience. I’ve dined on multiple occasions and have been impressed with the kindness and thoroughness of the waitstaff. I always feel like I’m visiting an old friend. And Rosario, the owner, is one of the most genuine people I’ve met in my life. He is a good person who takes pride in creating a high quality environment for his patrons. If you haven’t been already, please visit Pizza Secret. It’s well worth the trip.

    Report
39. SG

    SteakhouseGal

    Raum New York

    50 Bewertungen

    VIP
    3.0

    50 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 9. März 2019

    overall3food4service2ambience2

    It was probably not a fair day to judge Pizza Secret, huge concert at Barclays - the place had a hard time handling it. That said, the pizza was delicious (though it came cold) The dough was excellent, and the sauce was perfect. They are 3 blocks from Barclays and will definitely give them another try.

    Report
40. RC

    RobertaC

    Raum New York

    7 Bewertungen

    VIP
    1.0

    7 Bewertungen

    Besucht am 9. März 2019

    overall1food1service1ambience2

    Unfortunately, it was a disappointing dining experience. My expectations were high for a chef from Naples and sadly he missed the mark. Even the pizza was underwhelming. In addition, the staff were not prepared for service. I'm not sure when the restaurant opened, but it felt like day 1.

    Report