The Milling Room

4.6
icon/ic_reviewCreated with Sketch.
1718 Bewertungen
icon/ic_price_rangeCreated with Sketch.
31 bis 50 USD
icon/ic_cuisineCreated with Sketch.
Amerikanisch

Top-Etiketten:

Für Rendezvous geeignet
Nachbarschafts-Restaurant
Besondere Anlässe
Das The Milling Room serviert Ihnen amerikanische Küche zubereitet vom Küchenchef Scott Bryan in einer Tavernen-Atmosphäre im Herzen der Upper West Side.
Was 1718 Gäste sagen
Bewertungen insgesamt
Bewertungen können nur von Gästen gemacht werden, die in diesem Restaurant gegessen haben.
4.6Basierend auf kürzlich erfolgten Ratings
4.4
Essen
4.4
Service
4.7
Ambiente
4.0
Preis-Leistung
Lärm · Gemäßigt
92 % der Gäste würden das Restaurant einem Freund empfehlen
Sortieren nach
Filter
V
Raum New York
8 Bewertungen
vor einem Tag besucht
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Our brunch was well fresh, flavorful, and artfully prepared. The service will bring me back in to eat, both because of the helpful host as well as our attentive intuitive server. The ample space is bathed in natural light. Somewhat expensive but worth the experience.

Melden
SK
Raum New York
4 Bewertungen
vor 2 Tagen besucht
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Saturday night, what more can I say? Busy, noisy

Melden
SH
1 Bewertung
vor 3 Tagen besucht
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Food & service was great really enjoyed and would definitely recommend

Melden
OG
Raum New York
52 Bewertungen
vor 4 Tagen besucht
Gesamt4Essen3Service3Ambiente3

Dramatic space, cheery atmosphere, RAGINGLY loud, ok food and service... all in all I'd say its a GO.

Melden
HN
Raum New York
19 Bewertungen
vor 4 Tagen besucht
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Staff is always welcoming and efficient. Food continues to be outstanding. Never disappointed .

Melden
BT
Raum New York
22 Bewertungen
vor 6 Tagen besucht
Gesamt4Essen3Service5Ambiente4

Here’s the thing...The Milling Room is solid...I can’t really complain about too much (exceptions below) but I still find myself comparing this iteration with the Scott Bryan years! Bryan’s food was more refined and the menu a bit more balanced than the current place. I especially miss his touch with meat! The Milling Room now is very fish-heavy...and they do a fine job, but Bryan could really grill a nice steak. And that’s my main complaint. Get rid of the 60-day dried aged Strip Steak and bring back a damned Rib-Eye! A Rib-Eye is ALWAYS a better tasting cut and whatever they do to that Strip Steak ain’t good. Ditto their usual Filet ‘special’...it’s almost always a little tasteless. But if you stick with their pasta or fish mains, you’ll be fine. And corkage-free Tuesday’s is still a major draw. Service and ambience are top notch, but I’ll add a star if a couple of meat selections get added to an otherwise good menu.....

Melden
k
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 20. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Beautiful setting, terrific food, and excellent service. Plus, they are very aware of treating handicapped clients with dignity and accommodations.

Melden
S
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 19. Januar 2020
Gesamt4Essen4Service5Ambiente5

Molto bello, da visitare assolutamente per gustare dei piatti appetitosi

Melden
OT
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 19. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Sat at the bar and had a great experience. Our bartender was very attentive and the happy hour has awesome prices. $8 for glasses of wine.

Melden
LK
Raum New York
3 Bewertungen
Besucht am 19. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

We had a great birthday brunch--beautiful space, good service and really enjoyed the food.

Melden
LD
Indiana
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 18. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

We celebrated our oldest daughter’s birthday there. Food was excellent, good wine selection without being overwhelming. The team made her feel special by putting a candle on her dessert. It was very fun!

Melden
j
Philadelphia
11 Bewertungen
Besucht am 17. Januar 2020
Gesamt4Essen4Service4Ambiente4

Great atmosphere. Food was good. Service was excellent.

Melden
JS
Raum New York
7 Bewertungen
Besucht am 15. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Gorgeous setting. Delicious food. Perfect service.

Melden
H
Raum New York
44 Bewertungen
Besucht am 15. Januar 2020
Gesamt4Essen3Service5Ambiente4

Outstanding server: Katherin

Not happy about some of the menu changes and some of the pricing. The new version of your steak tartare is misguided and served with the wrong kind of bread, (thickly cut toasted white bread, too spongy). There also seems to be a lot less of the tartare than before. The octopus was ruined by an overly spicy sauce. Salad and soup were good although I do wonder whether those bits of mushroom in the squash soup were really chanterelles. They didn't look or taste like it.

Melden
CM
Raum New York
15 Bewertungen
Besucht am 15. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Coming onto the dining room wes very picturesque! It was very welcoming! The wait staff was attentive but not pushy, very helpful in describing the menu items & asking about any allergies (of which i did!) The food was served in an appetizing way & each course was Delish!! Thanx

Melden
l
Raum New York
10 Bewertungen
Besucht am 11. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service4Ambiente4

always good. First time I've seen the prix fixe dinner. The quality of choices was excellent. It was a particularly nice experience from a place that always delivers.

Melden
OT
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 7. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

I have to say our server Lizzy was absolutely fantastic. Every single time I go into Milling room she genuinely makes the experience worth it. She remembered my name after only being there one time months prior... She makes everyone feel so welcome, warm, and like we are guests her in home. She has an extensive knowledge not only on the menu, but also wine pairings, cultural an dining protocol, and my favorite her knowledge for food. I am not always the easiest of guests and I know that, but she truly makes my quirks welcome. Thank you Lizzy you are a gem!

Melden
OT
Raum New York
2 Bewertungen
Besucht am 7. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Excellent food, service, and atmosphere ! Highly recommend for a special night out.

Melden
OT
Raum New York
3 Bewertungen
Besucht am 5. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen4Service5Ambiente5

Small portions but hands down one of the best restaurants on the UWS

Melden
J
Raum New York
4 Bewertungen
Besucht am 5. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Went for 1st time brunch. The ambiance is good, excellent food and excellent service. Would definitely go back for lunch and or dinner. The history of the structure is very interesting as well!

Melden
e
Raum New York
17 Bewertungen
Besucht am 4. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Good for all of the above...

Melden
JE
Los Angeles
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 4. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Went on a date. Great atmosphere, food was delicious and so was their sauv blanc! I arrived early and sat at the bar. Great cocktail list.

Melden
PF
Raum New York
2 Bewertungen
Besucht am 4. Januar 2020
Gesamt4Essen5Service2Ambiente4

Excellent food but very indifferent service by our waitress.

Melden
TN
Raum New York
26 Bewertungen
Besucht am 3. Januar 2020
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

I took my sister here for a magical dining experience. Excellent meal, service and wine. One of our favorite places in the Upper West Side.

Melden
a
Raum New York
6 Bewertungen
Besucht am 31. Dezember 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente4

Always pleasing food variety in an informal quasi-romantic setting and superb service

Melden
A
San Francisco
3 Bewertungen
Besucht am 29. Dezember 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

We had such a great time at The Milling Room. The service was impeccable - your wine was always poured, your napkin was folded if you got up from the seat, and our server was extremely knowledgeable about the ingredients of the food because our table had several dietary restrictions! The food was AMAZING!! We got the octopus, ceviche, salad, and beef tartare appetizers for a table of 6 which were all amazing. Most of us got seafood which was cooked to perfection and very complex in flavor profile. Would definitely come back!

Melden
OT
Bath
2 Bewertungen
Besucht am 29. Dezember 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Excelente service! The waiter was super attentive and ready to help us to cover the needs of a toddler

Melden
OT
Raum New York
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 28. Dezember 2019
Gesamt4Essen5Service3Ambiente5

Food was excellent. Service was mediocre and forgettable

Melden
s
Miami
12 Bewertungen
Besucht am 27. Dezember 2019
Gesamt5Essen4Service5Ambiente5

Second wonderful dinner wit friends, and won't be lst

Melden
OT
San Francisco
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 26. Dezember 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Amazing restaurant! Food is great, outstanding service, perfect cocktails

Melden
NT
Raum New York
6 Bewertungen
Besucht am 24. Dezember 2019
Gesamt5Essen4Service4Ambiente5

We went for Christmas Eve dinner. The food was very good and the atmosphere is always fantastic there. It was quite busy, but we felt well taken care of despite the fact. I

Melden
D
Raum New York
2 Bewertungen
Besucht am 23. Dezember 2019
Gesamt4Essen4Service2Ambiente4

Food is excellent but the service leaves a lot to be desired. Drinks came out very slowly (I think our server might have forgotten to put our drinks order in), and we often couldn't find our server or anyone else for that matter to help us. It was probably just an off-night; we'll try again.

Melden
JW
Raum New York
7 Bewertungen
Besucht am 23. Dezember 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Great service at a quiet table to see a friend from long ago

Melden
LK
Raum New York
94 Bewertungen
Besucht am 22. Dezember 2019
Gesamt4Essen4Service4Ambiente5

First time here for brunch and was quite happy with the experience. We ordered eggs B, an omelette, and salmon with latkes. All were excellent. The salmon dish was somewhat small but nevertheless commendable. Enjoyed sitting under the skylight and the service was friendly and professional. Berry dessert was excellent too.

Melden
J
Philadelphia
22 Bewertungen
Besucht am 21. Dezember 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

A great dinner spot in the Upper West Side. We made reservations here on a Saturday night and had no problems once we arrived. The ambiance is perfect here with a nice open dining space. Food and drinks are outstanding. Highly recommend for a night out in the city.

Melden
E
Raum New York
45 Bewertungen
Besucht am 21. Dezember 2019
Gesamt4Essen4Service5Ambiente4

We stopped going to the Milling Room about a year ago after a disastrous meal under their new chef. This week, we returned & were delighted that the restaurant is back to being very well run and with a lovely, innovative menu and wonderful service. Our only complaint: the dining room was super chilly.

Melden
SR
Raum New York
4 Bewertungen
Besucht am 20. Dezember 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service4Ambiente5

Beautiful room. Comfortable seating. Delicious food. Attentive service.
Great experience.

Melden
OT
Raum New York
6 Bewertungen
Besucht am 18. Dezember 2019
Gesamt3Essen3Service5Ambiente5

Great service and space, but the food was underwhelming

Melden
CD
1 Bewertung
Besucht am 18. Dezember 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service5Ambiente5

Awesome restaurant! Elegant space, delicious food, and quality service.

Melden
OT
Raum New York
201 Bewertungen
Besucht am 16. Dezember 2019
Gesamt5Essen5Service4Ambiente5

Beautiful room and setting. Fantastic food -literally everything was delicious. Service is acceptable but doesn't rise to the level of the setting and the food. Overall, we love The Milling Room and can't wait to return.

Melden