Diners' Choice: Italian restaurants in Atlanta

OpenTable

Updated June 05, 2025

Looking for restaurants with the best overall Italian cuisine in Atlanta? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Di Paolo

4.9

4.9 (1908)

$31 to $50

Italian

Roswell

About the restaurant

di Paolo has been one of the most respected Italian restaurants in Atlanta since 1995. Our menu combines classic cuisine with modern flair. The food is simple yet creative, and changes with the seasons. Our executive chef Darin Hiebel has been featured in Best Chefs America.

Top review

Irving

Dined 6 days ago

When arriving at the restaurant, the surrounding area seemed a tad bit sketchy. However, after entering the restaurant, it was awesome! Food, Service, and menu was awesome! 5 out of 5!

Discover more

Experience

Sunday Wine Special – Enjoy 50% Off Bottles

il Giallo Osteria & Bar

4.9

4.9 (2857)

$31 to $50

Italian

Sandy Springs

About the restaurant

il Giallo is a culinary partnership between Leonardo Moura and Chef Jamie Adams, dedicated to transporting you to Italy's heart. The name 'il Giallo,' meaning both 'Yellow' and 'Mystery' in Italian, perfectly encapsulates our culinary philosophy.

'Yellow' signifies our unwavering commitment to using responsibly sourced, fresh ingredients, reminiscent of the sun's warmth, golden grains, and yolks.

'Mystery' embodies our ever-evolving menu, inviting you to explore new, exciting flavors inspired by the rich culinary tapestry of Italy.

We faithfully represent the northern part of Italy, while embracing the nation's culinary treasures as a whole. Our handmade pastas, inspired by the country's diverse landscapes, promise freshness and delight.

Beyond the food, il Giallo aspires to be an extension of your home, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere. We are more than just a restaurant; we are a place where unforgettable memories are created.

Top review

ChristyVIP

Dined 5 days ago

Pam is the best server ever! We love her. Il Giallo has the best bolognese in town

La Grotta

4.9

4.9 (3155)

$31 to $50

Italian

Buckhead

About the restaurant

Serving the finest in Northern & Regional Italian Cuisine, La Grotta offers old world charm and friendly, first class service and is located in the heart of Buckhead. A local favorite since 1978, La Grotta has received Best of Atlanta Award from Atlanta magazine since the mid 1980’s, prestigious DiRONA and AAA Four Diamond Awards since the early 90's.

La Grotta is tucked away in the heart of the Buckhead residential district and overlooks the lush gardens of the condo courtyard in which it is located. La Grotta literally means "the cave" in Italian and was named such for its cavernous and warm setting. The La Grotta staff is also well known and regarded for its vast knowledge of its customers, the food, diverse knowledge of languages (our staff speaks Italian, Spanish, French & German) and attention to detail. The menu specializes in Northern Italian cuisine with seasonal changes to reflect freshness of ingredients with a focus on locally grown produce.

Top review

StephanieVIP

Dined on Jun 5, 2025

A fantastic Birthday celebration with a group of Friends! Our servers did so much (as they always do) to make every dining experience at LaGrotta an extraordinary evening! Thanks to ALL who make it so!

Sugo

4.9

4.9 (4477)

$30 and under

Italian

Johns Creek

About the restaurant

Sugo is a restaurant in Duluth, Georgia, that serves Italian and Greek cuisine. The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere and offers a variety of classic and innovative dishes. Sugo is a great place to go for a special occasion or just a night out with friends. The restaurant also offers cooking classes, which are a great way to learn how to make some of your favorite dishes at home.

Top review

OpenTable Diner

Dined 2 days ago

Excellent service, food . Took the Hangar steak cooking class and it was outstanding! great cooking tips and food was great> Will definitely come back to restaurant for another cooking class and dinner

Discover more

Experience

$14 Pasta Tuesdays 2025

Experience

Throwback Thursday 2025

Experience

Weekend Prix Fixe - Taste of Summer

Antica Posta

4.9

4.9 (2125)

$31 to $50

Italian

Buckhead

About the restaurant

Antica Posta is an authentic Tuscan style restaurant located in the heart of the Buckhead entertainment district of Atlanta. Antica Posta combines fresh ingredients with traditional recipes for a dining experience that until now, was only available in our first restaurant in San Casciano, Italy. Marco and Alessandro Betti, owners, proudly invites you to taste the simple, flavorful dishes that have made Italian and Tuscan cooking the most appreciated cuisine in the world.
The Antica Posta of Buckhead, brings to our community the same genuine, sincere cuisine of Tuscany. Enjoy the delicate blend of meats, fish, vegetables, spices, and condiments that for centuries have pleased the palate of the most demanding Florentines.
Welcome to the first authentic Tuscan Restaurant in Georgia.

Top review

DickVIP

Dined 7 days ago

Love the wine selection as much as i love the food!

Valenza Restaurant

4.9

4.9 (3202)

$31 to $50

Italian

Brookhaven

About the restaurant

Valenza is a cozy, upscale Italian eatery in Brookhaven. It takes its name from a small village in the Piedmonte region of Northern Italy. Valenza is well known throughout the world for its artisan jewelry manufacturing which has earned it the nickname “city of gold”. The cuisine at VALENZA is inspired by the diverse culture of Northern Italy. Executive Chef Matt Swickerath’s focus is on classic and modern cooking methods using fresh seasonal and local ingredients to create a classic Italian menu with an updated culinary touch. The menu features a variety of antipasti, pasta, risotto and Italian entrees. Valenza has the heart and spirit of a cozy and warm Italian village café in an upscale setting. The dining room features venetian plastered walls with rustic oak and pine woods. Experience the warmth and elegance of Valenza when dining under the antique European candle chandeliers. Valenza offers a wonderful private dining room with seating for 30 guests.

Top review

KatieVIP

Dined on Jun 5, 2025

We love Valenza! Such an awesome neighborhood fine dining spot. We had Caleb last night and he made sure we had a wonderful experience!

Discover more

Popular dish

tiramisu

Pricci

4.8

4.8 (7291)

$50 and over

Italian

Buckhead

About the restaurant

We are a cashless restaurant and only accept Visa Mastercard Discover and American Express. Strict Dress Code Enforced.

Pricci is fun, stylish dining at its best complete with a contemporary Italian menu, dramatic interior and friendly service. This spin on classic cuisine results in a wide array of salads, pasta, pizza, meats and desserts that will dazzle with every bite. Esquire Magazine describes Pricci as “…a dazzlingly modern, very hip Italian restaurant,” one of America’s “20 Best New Restaurants.”

Top review

StephanieVIP

Dined 7 days ago

We very much enjoyed our delicious dinner at Pricci! Our service was impeccable and the spirits lively! It was a delightful evening, as always! Thanks to ALL who make it so!

Discover more

Popular dish

Dover Sole

Trattoria one41 - Johns Creek

4.9

4.9 (1059)

$31 to $50

Italian

Johns Creek

About the restaurant

Trattoria One 41 is vibrant and bustling with twenty tables and a "Cheers" like bar serving a menu of traditional and seasonal Italian dishes. The unmistakable in-town feel is complemented by its neighborhood warmth and charm.

Chef Marc Sublette's innovative take on classical, regional cooking begins with the finest, artisan ingredients and freshest, seasonal products. The distinctive and flavorful dishes are pure and satisfying and perfectly complemented by an outstanding international wine list.

The setting is warm and elegant and the mood quintessential Italian. In pleasant weather, alfresco dinning is offered, further adding to Trattoria One 41's year-round appeal.

Trattoria One 41 promotes a "grown up" environment. Open 7 nights, Monday - Saturday 14 years of age and older please; Sundays all ages are welcome.

Buon Appetitio!

Top review

LynVIP

Dined 6 days ago

Wonderful date night spot. Our favorite. Fantastic service and food is always great.

no. 246

4.8

4.8 (3815)

$30 and under

Italian

Decatur

About the restaurant

No. 246 offers “OG” red sauce, classic Italian – a reimagined direction that marks a new era for the Decatur gem, paying homage to the old-school, Italian dining scenes of yesteryear. From chefs Drew Belline and Ford Fry, the menu showcases the likes of spicy rigatoni vodka and a bowl of meatballs in gravy plus remixed, throwback to classics like calamari marinara, cheesy garlic bread, Nonna-approved pizzas and pastas and secondi crowd-pleasers like chicken al limone and shrimp scampi – plus classic cocktails and a carefully curated wine list of American and Italian standouts. For more information on our Chef's Counter, please visit our website.

Top review

Arlen

Dined 3 days ago

Great experience!!! Our waiter Drew went above and beyond to ensure we had a great experience. Will definitely be back. Everything was spectacular.

Discover more

4.7

4.7 (2065)

$31 to $50

Italian

Dunwoody

About the restaurant

Rafik Cressaty and his son, Patrick would like to welcome you to their family restaurant, Carbonara Trattoria, located in the heart of Dunwoody, Georgia. Carbonara is an inviting Italian restaurant with an ambiance reminiscent of Italy without sacrificing the southern charm of Atlanta. Warm earth tones, textured wall finishes and soft lighting are complemented by a menu featuring the finest fresh produce and ingredients. From antipasto and salads to fresh pastas and raviolis, quality meats and fresh seafood dishes, our Menu is inspired by the timeless recipes of the old north country. The father and son duo take you on a wonderful dining journey from the moment you walk in the door until the time you leave.

Reservations are not required but recommended. We offer a 15 minute grace period for reservations, if more time is needed please call.

Top review

JillVIP

Dined 2 days ago

We love coming here. Everything was great!!! We loved our meal and our waiter!!!

Explore Diners' Choice best of Atlanta

Explore more Diners' Choice lists