Celebrating thanksgiving the day after!
Farm to table is always a safe bet. But the difference here? Service. From start to finish we were treated as if we were the only ones being served. The place is warm, inviting, and welcoming. The servers are attentive and professional. And the food? Well, there is no place better within 100 miles.
This is our 4th year having ThanksGiving at Sedgley's. As usual the food was great! As was the service. In addition, if you are not into a traditional turkey dinner, the menu has a variety of other offerings. This year I had the braised short ribs. They were delicious.
Food was very good and the service was excellent. It's not cheap, but you get a good meal. We will be going back for sure.
Our first time at Sedgley’s and we will go again. Excellent food, excellent service in a beautiful place. Loved it❤️
Great experience with awesome service. The food was exceptional as well.
Took my adult children for their anniversary. It is the second set of married children to go. We have 2 more we are planning on bringing for their anniversary. The children were amazed and raved about the experience and quality of our meal. Would recommend.
This was our second visit in as many months. The first was before a performance at the nearby Theater at Monmouth on the recommendation of friends. The food and service were excellent although the staff was a bit stressed by the full house so the leisurely meal took almost two hours. Fortunately, we had allowed for that on the advice of the person who took our reservation. Although I had forgotten to mention my husband's allergies when I booked, the staff was helpful in accommodating them that night.
Recently, we returned with my mother as part of her 96th birthday weekend celebration. The owner and the server remembered us from our previous visit and, again, the food and service were excellent:
lobster/shrimp bisque and creamy vegetable soup to start, lamb and haddock for main courses, and apple crisp and ice cream sundae for dessert. I was feeling a bit ill but hadn't wanted to disappoint my mother by canceling the outing. Our server took note and tactfully offered gingerale and discretely boxed up my dinner and dessert. (My husband ate my meal the next night and declared the haddock - even after reheating - delicious, as well as the apple crisp.)
We definitely plan to return.
Overall we enjoyed the night. The waitress did mess up our drink order, although the drinks were excellent. And we had to ask twice for our dessert to go. I had the smoked scallops and shrimp. It was very good, but the orange marmalade sauce made it a little too sweet. My wife had the chicken pot pie with lobster. Again very good, but too many ingredients. Crackers and cheese (1st course) could've done without. Stuffed mushroom caps were great and huge. Salad was excellent as well. Everything included, a little high price wise.
The food is fabulous, waitstaff spot on and the venue is wonderful. A great spot for dinner with family and friends. Amazing all around and can’t wait to go back.
Great food and atmosphere highly recommend Sedgley Place
Very good food and the service was amazing. I will be back. THANK YOU
Duck breast was overcooked and tough. Small portions for sides of veggie hash and glazed beets and carrots, as well. Best part of the meal was the stuffed mushroom caps appetizer and desserts. Wife had the broiled scallop casserole which was excellent.
Always a pleasure to dine at Sedgley Place. Almost like dining with friends in their beautiful dining room. Menu was creative, meal was outstanding.
This was our second time at the Seckel place , we love it there . We have been there both times for special occasions and it was exactly that ! Both times our experience was outstanding . We look forward to the next special event so we can can return .
I have recommended you to many of my clients and friends in hopes that they can have a wonderful time as well.
Went there for my anniversary with my wife, and we could not have been more pleased. Our waitress was pleasant, prompt and wonderful. The food was the best meal that I have had in 2019 so far. I can't wait to go back there again.
From the moment we were seated, we felt like valued customers. Our server was attentive and friendly, the service was excellent and the food wonderful. My filet mignon was nothing short of perfect! I definitely want to return to try other items on the menu. Well worth the travel.
First time dining at this unique place. We will definitely recommend to friends and will return for another excellent experience.
I love going to Sedgleys the food is ezcellent. And the waitresses know the menu and explain it very well. My husband and I been going there every year for our Anniversay.
I hadn't been to Sedgley since I was in high school (1988) and was happy to see things hadn't changed much. My daughter and I arrived 5 minutes late due to no sign on Rt. 202, when seated we were offered an appetizer which we were not informed was not included in our meal. We were not finished our crackers and cheese before the soup came then promptly the soup...it all felt too rushed! I realize that the seatings at Sedgley are timed but I do not enjoy being rushed through my courses. Our table overlooked the cove of vinyl siding:(
It may be another 30 years before I return!
Very pleased with our dinning experience. The 5 course meal was a good value and well prepared and presented. Service was very good. The courses arrived as soon as the previous course was finished. I would have preferred a little slower pace with more time for conversation between courses. Ambiance of the old inn was very good. Menus choices were traditional and tasty. I would not hesitate to recommend this dinning experience.
Beautiful place with excellent food and service expertly timed for wonderful evening. Could not have been nicer
The restaurant is elegant and staff a very friendly. This was my second time and I enjoyed the meal with my boyfriend and I like the length of the meal and that each item is brought out in order.
Only issue was the baked stuffed mushrooms were extremely salty. The stuffing was good as always but the mushrooms seem to have been brined. I could not finish the mushrooms, ate the stuffing though. My husband also had them and felt the same.
Everything else was great!
Wonderful waitress great service
1st time here, we loved it!
Food was excellent! We had prime rib and filet mignon cooked perfectly.
All the staff was attentive and pleasant.
We will definitely be going back.
We were there for our anniversary. Although we didn’t tell them, they remembered from last year.
Everything was fantastic! I highly recommend the mushroom caps with stuffing. Delicious!
Excellent food, wonderful staff. Meal was not rushed. Looking forward to going back.
Four of us went to dinner and had the 5-course meal at the 5:00 seating. We were greeted and seated immediately upon arrival. Our server was upbeat, helpful with suggestions, attentive to our needs for beverages and refills, and a pleasure to interact with.
As for the food, we found the cheese and crackers to be underwhelming. The cheese spread was bland and could have been eliminated. The bread and butter was much better. I had the French onion soup which was delicious. The broth had a deep rich flavor and the cheese was generous and a great complement to the onions and broth. I ordered the "airline" chicken breast with the ragout of lobster and gnocchi. This was just wonderful. The chicken had a lovely flavor accented with herbs. The lobster was generously portioned, much more than expected. The gnocchi were enjoyable but didn't stand out compared with the lobster and chicken. I ordered the flour-less chocolate cake with raspberry coulis for dessert, but save it for the following day. Even then, it was delicious: rich, creamy, deep chocolate flavor, and the coulis provided the right counterpart of tartness.
Overall, it was a really enjoyable meal and very reasonably priced. We spent close to 2 hours, and it felt perfect. I definitely plan to pay Sedgely Place a return visit.
I always enjoy my time at Sedgley Place. The food is amazing, the service is always great, and we always have a wonderful experience!
Celebrated our 34th Anniversary. The experience from start to finish was perfect. The food was fresh, hot, and tasty. We loved the entree options. My husband got the eggplant parmigiana. I got the pork. We shared shrimp cocktail at the start of our meal (extra charge) and the cocktail sauce was one of the best I’ve ever had. We received a complimentary glass of champagne to celebrate our anniversary. We can’t wait to go back. Also looking forward to the Sedgley Cafe serving breakfast starting this September. 😍
A great first time experience. Good, drinks, atmosphere was amazing.
From what others have said about Sedgley Place, it was everything and more!!
Such a comfortable atmosphere. The staff is friendly and helpful, and the food is absolutely delicious!
My second time and it was as enjoyable as the first time! Great place
Great experience! The food was delicious and there was a lot more food in each course than I was expecting. I’ll be prepared to eat more next time!
What a wonderful place to share special times with family and friends. The food is always spectacular and the staff are always great.
We very much enjoyed our meal at Sedgley Place. However, I had looked at the menu before we arrived and saw they offered Ahi Tuna, which I was looking forward to ordering. When we arrived they had changed the menu and were offering Monk fish instead, was a little disappointed. I ended up ordering the zucchini ravoili which was delicous.
The restaurant was great. However,your rating sight does not work correctly, it took me 3 tries to complete the review. FIX IT!