Atwater's in The Herrington
Awesome place for special occations. On the banks of Fox River
Everything great. Just family with kids that were s little noisey.
That took away from our experience. No fault of restaurant
The experience at Atwater’s is always special. The service is top notch and the food is very good. Great place for a special occasion. Very quaint.
Food is delectable and service top notch. Truly a gem of a place!
This place is always nice to have celebrations with my family
My favorite place for dinner, the room itself is a joy but then the service, noise level and food are the extras.
After reading and hearing wonderful things about the restaurant, we decided to go there to celebrate on our honeymoon (we were staying in the Inn). We noted on the reservation that it was our honeymoon, and we told our server, but we didn't even get a "congratulations." Other diners who overheard us tell the server our news congratulated us, so I know that our server heard it. Our experience was a major disappointment, both the service (which was inattentive) and the food. We ordered a roasted beet salad that was out of a bag with nothing exciting about it, and it had zero flavor. The soup was ho-hum and not very hot, and our entree was a monotone gray color. We ordered the day's special of whitefish with fingerling potatoes and charred artichokes. While the char did have a nice flavor, the plate and entree had zero finesse to it, and who serves gray artichokes at this caliber of a restaurant? It was very unappetizing to look at, which is a big contributor to the overall dining experience. We talked about it with the server and she didn't seem to care. Atwater failed to impress us whatsoever, in fact, it was a huge disappointment and a dining experience we regret for such a special occasion.
Excellent food, superior and attentive service, quiet and romantic atmosphere.
We celebrated our 40th wedding anniversary and Atwater's was the perfect place to have a special dinner. Highly recommended!!
Wonderful dinner for a special occasion! :) Looking forward to returning.
Loved the special treats the chef sent out & my birthday dessert. Everything was delicious & artfully prepared. The only suggestion I’d have is the risotto was delicious but too heavy for an entree. I was so glad we decided to share meals to taste a little of everything so the risotto was more like a side dish. We also had a delicious breakfast on Sunday. We’ll be back!
Perfect venue for a quiet and elegant 65th anniversary celebration for our parents. The menu was innovative without being goofy (i.e. no "deconstructed," "foamed," etc). The chef offers perfectly cooked entrees with a variety of carefully matched garnishes that make every bite a little different and a delightful surprise. Service was attentive but not intrusive. Ambiance was rich and elegant.
Excellent food in a perfect setting for a quiet or romantic dinner. Staff was exceptional.
Quiet and cozy restaurant. Food and service excellent!
Celebrating a promotion at work and our daughters recent engagement
Had dinner with friends and a great time was had by all! Excellent restaurant but a bit overpriced.
The food was impeccably prepared. We were treated like royalty.
Birthday lunch. Beautiful restaurant with fabulous food.
Outstanding setting. Delicious lunch.
Great Food and service. The lamb was delicious as well as the desert.
Everything was amazing! I had a wonderful experience!
Dinner at the Atwater is always special.
Excellent drinks and food. Very good service and a beautiful setting. Romantic setting by the river. Highly recommend
Beautiful setting and great food!
My son and his girlfriend were in town for weekend, we wanted a place where we could relax and enjoy a long lunch. It was festival of the vine in Geneva so was worried about noise level. Unnecessary. The food, hamburger and couple salads were wonderful. Great day!
Both food and service were outstanding. They went over and above to help us celebrate our anniversary. Water glass was never empty. We will definitely go back. It was a great experience.
The food is always outstanding. The quiet and elegant atmosphere sets the tone for a romantic evening.
Pretty place and good restaurant. A nice way to enjoy our wedding anniversary.
The food is outstanding. The service great. The atmosphere incredible. You can’t go wrong with anything you choose from the menu. We’ve never been disappointed dining here.
Beautiful place with wonderful food and service! Will definately go back!
Lovely atmosphere! Beautiful location! Fine dining at it's best! Strongly recommended!
Excellent all around! Wait staff was great and the food was awesome!
Both steaks, while a high quality of meat and seasoned well, were extremely over cooked.
Atwater’s has a wonderful location on the Fox River. Indoor and outdoor seating but be prepared to dine quietly inside. Great dining experience. The chef sent out ceviche on a chip to cleanse the palette and the best fresh baked cream puffs ever for dessert. Service was awesome as expected. Prices are high but not crazy high all considered.
Good food, service and ambience!
Ambiance was very comfortable along with the quiet service of the staff. Lunch was 2 of their fish offerings. Delicious. Will come back again.
Beautiful view, quiet and cozy
This is fine dining! And a perfect place to have celebrated our wedding anniversary.
Very nice room! Beautiful view. Food was very good....filet and lamb chops. We enjoyed the entire experience. Recently moved to Geneva and have been wanting to try Atwater's. It did not disappoint!
Our server, Renee, was excellent! Food was expensive but good! Chef sent out a few extras throughout the meal which was very nice! Chef is obviously very good at his profession!