Die besten Gastro-pubs in Shelter Island

My partner and I were craving hamburgers on a beautiful summer evening, so we looked forward to sitting in the lovely garden at Sag Harboe Tavern. The burgers were fabulous — thick and very tasty — with their own secret mixture; I tried to get the recipe — lol. The cottage fries weren't crispy enough. They had an odd texture and flavor. They could definitely be improved upon. The service was excellent, and the ambiance is always so vibrant, yet serene. Always love dining at Sag Harbor Tavern. Thank you!

You just can’t go wrong with this restaurant. We have had everything from private events, simple pub food and gourmet meals here and it’s always just terrific. Theresa took great care of us and made a wedding anniversary dinner perfect. She and all the staff are really amazing. The food is always great. If you haven’t tried the brunch yet- you are missing out. Then, to top it off, the view is spectacular. This is just a super well run restaurant at a beautiful golf course. The management and all the staff really do a great job here.

Food and service were outstanding! Extremely noisy although not overly crowded. Weather permitting, suggest seating area outside. Tamer.

Great food, service, and vibes. What a gem of a place. We look forward to returning.

We had waitstaff who were very attentive and on top of everything! The meals were delicious! There were 8 of us, and all the plates were clean. I would highly recommend.