Die besten Restaurants mit einem Tasting-Menü in City Island

Always fabulous — elegant, professional yet warm service.

Outstanding restaurant! From appetizers to dessert. Out server, Aldo, was exceptional and knows the menu to answer all questions. He paid attention to details we had about items ordered and all items were delivered as requested. All service was extremely attentive. This was our first visit and honestly, we do not know how we did not visit long ago. We live 5 minutes away. This defines the best Italian restaurant in the Scarsdale area! Desserts are numerous & are also a tasty treat! We will definitely return as this is the best of the best!

We dined at Roberto’s for the first time, actually our first time on Arthur Ave. we are Italian and eat at fine restaurants all the time, all over the world. Our experience at Roberto’s was one of the best ever. From ambiance to cocktails to service to excellent food and wine, it was perfect. Each food selection was seasoned and cooked to perfection with the freshest of ingredients. While getting to Arthur Ave for us is quite the hike, it was worth it and I am thinking about when I can go back. The valet service rounds out the perfect dining experience.

Overall delicious food! Even my 2 year old niece enjoyed and ate everything we ordered!

Alan provided top notch service. Gluten free concerns were so well handled. He knew details about every menu item (including allergens) and made sure everything was perfect. Food was great!! Thanks Alan!!!