The Beach Plum - Permanently Closed

Bewertungen für The Beach Plum - Permanently Closed von Gästen, die dieses Restaurant besucht haben. Basierend auf den neusten Bewertungen.

1. OT

   OpenTable-Gast

   Greater Boston1 Bewertung

   4.0

   Besucht am 11. Oktober 2015

   1. Gesamt 4
   2. Essen 5
   3. Service 4
   4. Ambiente 3

   The food and service were very good, but the noise level made it difficult to carry on a table conversation (the dining room was full). It's BYOB. The sunset from the dining room was a nice bonus.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

2. W

   Whatisareviewnickname

   London4 Bewertungen

   5.0

   Besucht am 11. Oktober 2015

   1. Gesamt 5
   2. Essen 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiente 5

   Honestly, this was one of the best meals I've ever had. I've eaten at Le Bernadin, Bouley, Eleven Mad, you name it, and this matched them toe for toe. I used to eat here when my parents used to bring me out there at the end of our summer share in Edgartown, but, to be honest, the food was very pedestrian. What a phenomenal turn around. The food was unpretentious but exquisitely finished. Giant ricotta gnocchis, achingly crunchy donuts, and the most perfectly toasted marble rye one could envision. Katz's would be furious tasting this bread. The view, as always, was spectacular. Our server, Jonathan, was so helpful and made the best recommendations. He personally guaranteed we'd love the ceviche and could not have been more right. Oy, these superlatives are starting to get annoying I'm sure. I will end by saying that I will absolutely be coming back when the Beach Plum reopens it's doors in 2016.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

3. SG

   SGMD

   Minneapolis49 Bewertungen

   2.0

   Besucht am 4. Oktober 2015

   1. Gesamt 2
   2. Essen 3
   3. Service 4
   4. Ambiente 5

   Two years ago the Beach Plum became, briefly, the best restaurant on Martha's Vineyard. An old, dowdy, boring place was transformed, both physically and with a new chef, with some truly exciting food. Alas, he left and last year the place was awful. This year, another chef and, well, a work in progress but much progress is needed. The basics are sound: beautiful room, good service, outstanding ingredients (the tuna and the chicken must be some of the best on the Island). But the preparations were utterly incoherent. Nothing worked. And the prices, even by Island standards, are truly insane. We will not return and we would not recommend it unless the food improved and/or the prices dropped to the level of other, and currently much better, establishments both Up-Island and in Edgartown.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

4. c

   chas

   Charlotte59 Bewertungen

   4.0

   Besucht am 20. September 2015

   1. Gesamt 4
   2. Essen 4
   3. Service 4
   4. Ambiente 4

   Our second visit this Summer..and once again, a wonderful evening of delicious fare. Not to be missed if you're visiting the Island. The new chef has resurrected both the dining quality and reputation of the Beach Plum after two fairly dismal years at the hands of a much less talented chef. When you read the reviews, make sure you consider only this year's ratings. Order the "Chicken Butter" and Ceviche appetizers for a start. Entrees..they are all exceptional.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

5. b

   beachpluminn

   Raum New York3 Bewertungen

   5.0

   Besucht am 13. September 2015

   1. Gesamt 5
   2. Essen 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiente 5

   The Beach Plum Inn is one of the best restaurants we've ever been to - and my girlfriend and I have eaten at some of the finest restaurants in the world. Set on charming hillside lot, overlooking the small fishing village of Menemsha and the sea beyond, the views are as spectacular as the food. The service is friendly and relaxed, yet attentive. We brought a bottle of Mum's and had an amazing night on her birthday. The menu changes daily (as any good farm to table restaurant should) so I can't make any specific recommendations, but everything is likely to be delicious.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

6. P

   Pamsy

   Greater Boston16 Bewertungen

   3.0

   Besucht am 11. September 2015

   1. Gesamt 3
   2. Essen 4
   3. Service 3
   4. Ambiente 2

   But for the food, Beech Plum was a big disappointment this year from the very start. We expect more from this highly rated and high priced restaurant. We booked on Open Table because we called to make a reservation for the night of our anniversary, left a message, and never got a return call. We requested a table for two, inside next to a window for our anniversary. When they called the day defore to confirm our reservation I repeated the request. They didn't seat us at the window and after we were seated we noticed a nearby empty table for two. We didn't ask to be reseated. By their own admission, they were slammed unexpectedly and understaffed. The best thing about BP is enjoying a glass of BYOB wine on the beautiful terrace watching the sunset over Menemsha Bay. No waitstaff was outside to offer wine glasses or pour wine. We went back inside to ask and were told someone was out there. Not true. Finally someone brought jelly jars - yes, jelly jars - to a nearby group. We asked for them, too, and never got them. By that time, it was time for our reservation. We loved the sunset even without the wine. The place was super noisy. As there was no outside dining that night because they were setting up for a wedding the next day, I think they crammed more people inside. No wine glasses, just jelly jars! Our waiter told us they were short because they had returned their rented glasses earlier this week. Really? With a wedding the next day? We had to ask for our bottle of wine to be opened. Eventually we got real wine glasses. Our dinners were very good though not exceptional - yellow fin tuna and slow cooked lamb shank with polenta in a rich broth. The greens, radish , and goat feta cheese salad would have been better if you could find more than a few morsels of cheese. Not enough ingredients for the unexpected crowd? Our waiter and the entire staff were pleasant but in a hurry. They couldn't be attentive. We sensed their frustration.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

7. B

   Buddy

   Greater Boston3 Bewertungen

   5.0

   Besucht am 5. September 2015

   1. Gesamt 5
   2. Essen 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiente 4

   my wife and are vegetarian and the waiter asked the chef to prepare something special. and it was: a delicious mushroon, cherry tomatoe saute on silky potatoe puree, all with local ingredients. it was beautifully seasoned and just the right potion size. this is an exceptional dining experience.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

8. C

   Citymom

   Raum New York68 Bewertungen

   4.0

   Besucht am 3. September 2015

   1. Gesamt 4
   2. Essen 4
   3. Service 5
   4. Ambiente 5

   It seems to b a trend on the island to offer small plates. This restaurant follows the trend. But a strange menu. Scallops with pork belly???Prices r inflated due to byob but $47 for chicken is still hard to swallow. Chicken pate was good but hard to know what to expect when they call it chicken butter. Service was fine. Things came hot but not sure I would go out of way again to get there. Chilmark tavern better option in my opinion. Bit noisier without the smaller ambiance but better food
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

9. J

   Jane

   Greater Boston4 Bewertungen

   5.0

   Besucht am 2. September 2015

   1. Gesamt 5
   2. Essen 5
   3. Service 4
   4. Ambiente 5

   It was a delightful evening at The Beach Plum restaurant...good service explaining the menu, excellent food, a bit noisy with a full house of diners.
   

   War diese Bewertung hilfreich?

10. BM

    BenjaminM VIP

    Raum New York11 Bewertungen

    5.0

    Besucht am 2. September 2015

    1. Gesamt 5
    2. Essen 5
    3. Service 5
    4. Ambiente 5

    Lovely time! Perfect place to celebrate post engagement with family.
    

    War diese Bewertung hilfreich?